Adult-FanFiction.org : Buffy

Buffy's Bad Bet	By : Oric13 Category: BtVS AU/AR > Threesomes/Moresomes Views: 54990 -:- Recommendations : 1 -:- Currently Reading : 4
Disclaimer: I do not own Buffy the Vampire Slayer (BtVS), nor any of the characters from it. I do not make any money from the writing of this story.

Chapter List
- 4
- 5
Featuring
Buffy Summers (portrayed by Sarah Michelle Gellar)
Faith (portrayed by Eliza Dushku)
Dawn Summers (portrayed by Michelle Trachtenberg)
Janice Penshaw (portrayed by Amber Tamblyn)
Chapter 5 – Summers Punishment Strapping (f/F, D/s, spank, humil, exhib, voy, mc?)
'Awkward!' Buffy cringed at being caught red-handed fooling around with Dawnie's 14 year old friend by her sisters. 'But at least I wasn't going down on her.'
Blinking in surprise, she only now noticed that Janice was standing several feet further away and the teen's bald cunny and round butt were once again covered by her tight little skirt. 'Huh. Bitch is FAST.'
It was almost like she daydreamed the entire thing, except... yes, looking closely her sharp eyes could just about see the white stick end of the lollipop wiggling around a bit right beneath the hemline of Janice's miniskirt. 'She's still got her lollipop up her snatch!' Buffy realized with a jolt of arousal.
“Sorry to keep you waitin’ for so long, B,” Faith said with a mock apologetic expression on her face. “But mom did one helluva job hiding the S.P.S..”
“Mission accomplished, though,” Dawn grinned as she menacingly twirled the leather strap around before slapping it threateningly into the palm of her hand like an accomplished dominatrix. “Owww!! Shit, that hurts!” she squealed while frantically waving her sore hand around, making Janice, Faith, and even Buffy, laugh.
“That’s not where you’re supposed to be slapping that thing, Dawn,” a still chuckling Faith noted.
“Ha-ha, yes I know,” the sheepish looking teen replied, frowning annoyed at her snickering friends before finally narrowing her eyes at her giggling big sister, who instantly stopped laughing upon seeing Dawn’s dark look.
Her bruised ego somewhat soothed by her sibling’s meek attitude, Dawn strutted over to the bend-over, bare-naked blonde and slapped her possessively on the ass. “I know you must be eager to go to the party that Faith is throwing in your honor, so we better get started on your whipping, Sis.”
“Uhhh... no rush! How ‘bout a nice game of cards instead?” Buffy nervously babbled, bringing a small smirk to her younger sister’s lips as the other girls giggled.
Despite desperately wanting this mind-boggling humiliation to be over with, the tiny slayer suddenly vividly recalled the blazing inferno that devilish strap always managed to ignite in her poor lil hiney. In fact, she'd always had this sneaking suspicion that the Summers Punishment Strap might somehow be magically empowered.
“Oh, so NOW you suddenly wanna play cards,” Dawn mockingly stated. “Remember all the times I asked you to play with me when you couldn't be bothered?”
Buffy looked embarrassed as she shamefully recollected the numerous times she blew off her attention starved kid sister. “I've got time for you now, Dawnie,” she softly said.
“Well, now I'm too busy whipping your ass,” Dawn angrily spit out as she struck her sister's ass with the heavy strap.
WHACKK!! “Oucchh!” Buffy cried out as the hard leather landed heavily on her already aching behind.
'It's actually happening! My bratty baby sister is whipping my bare butt!' she dazedly realized. The most humiliating scenario she'd ever imagined had come true! And just like she'd feared, her other -adopted- sister was there to witness it all (and so was Dawnie's best friend!).
WHACKKK!!! "Owwww!!" The sting of the Summers Punishment Strap was even worse than she remembered! But then the previous times she didn't just have a bare bottomed slayer spankin' shortly before her whipping.
It suddenly occurred to Buffy that their mom had never given her more than thirty with the strap. And that there's no way she could possibly take twenty-five lashes from Dawn AND another 25 from Janice on her slayer-spanked behind! Yet insanely enough, she'd pretty much offered it to them herself. And they'd undoubtedly take full advantage of this rare opportunity, especially Dawnie. 'I'm sooo fucked!'
Studying the first two red stripes she just laid across her eldest sibling's stuck-up ass, Dawn's satisfied expression suddenly turned apologetic.
"Oh jeez, I'm sorry," Dawn said causing Buffy to gaze up at her with hopeful eyes. "Where are my manners! I didn't even ask if you maybe wanna go first, Janice?"
"Hey, she's your sister, so it's only fair that you get to whip her cute round butt first, Dawn," her friend answered with a smile.
The three brunettes snickered at the obvious crestfallen look on Buffy's face. "Awww, I think B was hopin' that she might get off lightly," Faith teasingly observed.
"Yeah, NOT gonna happen," Dawn grinned while swinging the strap around in the air, gleefully building up the tension for her audience but especially her anxiously watching beautiful, butt-naked, big sister.
This amazing opportunity to beat Buffy's bare ass was truly a dream come true. Many times she'd spied on her sibling's punishment sessions, stealthily stroking her wet cunny while wishing it was HER blistering that perfect butt.
And now it finally IS her!
Milking this extraordinary occasion for all that it's worth, she made Buffy wait almost an entire dread-filled minute before finally bringing the strap down with all her might across those enticing pert, pink globes.
TWACCKKK!!!! "Yowwwwww!!!" Buffy yelled wide-eyed.
The bend-over blonde didn't have to wait long for the next stroke, or the one after that.
CRACCK!! ... WHACKK!!! “Dawnie, please! I’m sorry,” Buffy pitifully begged.
“Shut it, Sis. You know you’ve had this coming for a looong time,” the youngest Summers sternly said as she struck a swift succession of lashes across her sibling’s perfectly round, rosy-red buttocks.
WHACK!! CRACKKK!!! TWACKK!! “OOOooohhh!”
"You tell her, D!" Faith called out while beaming at the young brunette like any proud big sister would while watching her beat the stuffing out of their stuck-up sibling's bubble-butt. OK, so Red hadn't said anything about including lil sis in B's punishment regime. But even though her own ass might have to pay the price for goin' slightly off plan, she's still hella stoked that her darlin' D also got some sweet payback on their bitchy big sister.
WHACCKK!!! "That's for neglecting your family!" Dawn angrily informed her red-cheeked sister as she really started layin' into the (now by far) reddest set of cheeks.
"And friends!" TWACKKK!!! "Ooooowwww!!"
"For tattling on me!!" WHACCKKK!!!! "Yooooowwwww!!!"
"And... for being such a selfish, self-righteous bitch for so long!" CRACKKK!!! "AAAaaaaaaahhhhh!!!" 'It seriously feels like my buns are about to ignite!'
Feeling dizzy and disoriented from the constant humiliation, the rapidly increasing burn in her buttocks, and another kinda burning in her loins, Buffy's befuddled mind was still trying to make sense of the fact that she was actually getting a bare-assed whipping from her kid sister.
“That's the stuff, D!” Faith practically cheered. “Give it to her good. Make her squeal for ya!”
“Yeah, you go, girl!” Janice excitedly chimed in. “Whoop that pretty ass.”
Judging from the way they were cheering her on, Faith and Janice also seemed to feel that she deserved this degrading painful punishment. 'That's because you ARE a selfish, self-righteous bitch,' the penetrating voice of her conscience once again helpfully explained. 'You've been a bad friend and a lousy big sister. And one lil spanking isn't enough to make up for all that. So, yes, you totally have this coming.'
All this craziness, the constant humiliation and corporal punishment, and her just... going along with it all, finally started to make some sense to the bewildered blonde. They must be right. She DID deserve to be punished, for neglecting her friends and family and for being such a bitch to them. And though she was apparently too big a bitch to initially admit it to herself, subconsciously she must've agreed with her sisters—THAT's why she's letting herself be punished and humiliated by them. After all, who better to decide her punishment than the two people closest to her, who love her most, and who also have been hurt the most by her neglectful, bitchy behavior. 'If I'd been a better, more attentive, big sister then maybe Dawn wouldn’t be sucking off seniors at her age,’ she considered contritely.
TWACKKK!!! "Owwwwww!!"
“I'm sorry! I realize now that I've been a bad sister,” the teary-eyed slayer ruefully acknowledged while sending her strap wielding sibling an apologetic look from between her wide-spread legs. "To both of you," she added, looking over at her surprised looking sister slayer. “And I promise I’ll do better from now on.”
Halting the whipping, Dawn looked even more surprised than Faith, but then a smile broke out on her face. “Thanks, Buffy, it really means a lot to hear you say that.”
"Yeah, that's pretty cool of you, B."
Despite her humiliating predicament and aching ass, Buffy smiled back at her sisters and the three Summers siblings actually shared a moment where they felt closer to one another than ever before.
“Awwww! Sisterly bonding, how sweet.” Janice cooed with a sappy smile.
Dawn’s sweet smile suddenly turned wicked. “Still gonna whip you good, though.”
Feeling strangely at peace with her punishment, Buffy nodded solemnly, “I know, and I realize now that I deserve every lash.”
Bending over a bit further, the naked blonde invitingly wiggled her throbbing cherry cheeks at her little sister. “So give it to me good, Dawnie,” Buffy earnestly repeated Faith’s earlier encouragement as she braced herself for her sister’s strap. “Make me squeal for ya.”
"Oh, I will, Sis," Dawn breathlessly promised. Her bare-naked, bossy big sister's complete surrender was such a humongous turn-on that the young teen was literally trembling with excitement. "Gonna make you squeal like a little bitch."
“Awwww! Sisterly S&M, how sweet,” Faith parroted Janice, smiling impishly as she avidly watched this twisted sister act unfold.
Hungrily eying her beautiful sibling's oh-so-spankable ass, Dawn licked her lips as she drew back the strap before once again striking it down as hard as she could, several times in a row, unto those juicy jiggling cheeks and indeed managed to make the mighty slayer squeal like a little bitch.
And Buffy squealed a LOT as her youngest sister skillfully strapped her bare behind. Just like during her spanking from Faith, she willingly surrendered to the pain and made a shameless spectacle out of herself.
TWACCKKK!!! "Oooowwwww!! My hineyyyy!" the tiny blonde wailed to the hilarity of her captivated audience as she shook her glowing red butt around like it's on fire.
Though her own mortifying behavior made her face burn almost as red as her ass, Buffy couldn't help herself. Something inside her was edging her on to act like the naughty little girl she felt like right now. Telling her she deserved this humiliation as much as her butt-whipping; that she needed to debase herself to please her long neglected siblings.
CRAACCKK!!!! "Aaaaahhhh!!! Boo-hoo! My poor lil Buffy butt!!" the formerly proud slayer wept without restrain. That one in particular had them in stitches. Dawn laughed so hard that it took a while before she was able to resume the whipping.
****BtVS****
"OK, just three more lashes, Sis, and then we're done," Dawn announced with obvious regret. "So how 'bout we make those last ones really count?"
Buffy gawked up at her youngest sister with dazed, disbelieving eyes. "I think you already made everyone of 'em count, Dawnie," she spoke with a tired, awed, and slightly hoarse voice. "Not even mom whipped my ass as good as you just did!"
"Yeah, that was pretty damn epic, D," Faith huskily said as she excitedly stared at her sister slayer's thoroughly beaten ass. The dark slayer 's nipples were so hard they were practically poking a hole thru her tight, belly-baring T-shirt.
"Totes! I think I can, like, actually see heat lines radiating from her burning red butt," Janice spoke with obvious awe.
"Aw, shucks, guys," Dawn said, attempting to sound modest but looking pleased as Punch. "I did okay, I guess, but I'm sure I could do better."
"Don't sweat it, D, you'll probably get another go at it soon enough," Faith grinned evilly. "After all, B's still my bitch for about 45 more hours. And knowing big sis, she's gonna rack up plenty more punishment in that time."
"You're like the best sister EVER," Dawn smiled.
The two beautiful brunettes turned their smiles towards their non-smiling sister, obviously expecting some kind of angry or pleading response from her.
Yet somewhat surprisingly, that didn't happen. It might've taken her some time, but the beaten blonde was finally learning. She knew that any objections would only make that second whipping more likely, and pleading hadn't done her much good, either, so far. Besides, she realized now that she had this coming.
"You won't need to punish me again. I'll be a good girl, I promise!" Buffy sincerely said while gazing shyly at her siblings thru her wide-spread legs.
Their big sister's uncharacteristic meek attitude made the two brunettes exchange excited looks and positively beam with delight.
Stepping closer, Faith affectionately stroked her sibling's beet red ass—awed at the heat radiating from it. She gleefully noted that her usually straight-laced sister slayer now accepted this intimate caress without any protest and, despite their attentive audience, even seemed to welcome it. "Yeah, you say that NOW, B, but we both know you'll be back to bein' a big ole bitch once your cute bubble-butt has cooled off."
"No, really, I've learned my lesson!" the petite blonde earnestly declared. "I'll be respectful and obedient from now on."
"Oh, really?" Dawn smirked. "Well, then let's test your newfound obedience, big sister."
All eyes turned to the youngest Summers and a hush of anticipation filled the room.
"So you agree with us that you've been acting like an asshole, right, Buffy?" Dawn questioned with a sugary sweet voice.
"Uhhh, yes Dawnie?" Buffy agreed, somewhat confused. They'd kinda settled on "bitch" so far, but "asshole" wasn't untrue, either.
"Good. Then, as part of your punishment, I think you should show us."
"... huh? Show you what," Buffy questioned confused.
"Your asshole," Dawn clarified with an impish grin.
There was a moment of stunned silence, immediately followed by Faith and Janice laughing their asses off.
"What?!" Once again, Buffy's blush almost rivaled that of her other cheeks. "B-but you can already see my... my... anus in this position," she shyly reminded her sibling.
"I know," Dawn said, smiling in that particularly wicked way which was SO Faith-like that you could easily believe those two had been sisters from birth. "This is more about you showing us your tight lil asshole, Sis."
Buffy's mouth opened and closed like a fish as she gawked at her surprisingly kinky youngest sister. Switching her gaze to Faith, she saw that both her sisters' beautiful faces shared the same excited smirk. And Janice's expression wasn't much different, either, she noticed, as the giggling brunette came in for a closer look.
They were all so very eager to watch her debase herself even further for their pleasure, you could practically cut the sexual tension with a knife. Obviously they got off on her sexual humiliation as much as she apparently did.
'So just give them what they want,' her persuasive inner voice suggested. 'Remember, you still owe them plenty of penance for your bitchy, selfish behavior.'
That's right, she did. And her sisters clearly wanted to collect. Yet to actually obey this obscene demand would mean giving her kid sister forever the upper hand in their relationship. And that's putting it mildly. Letting lil Dawnie whip her naked ass (in front of witnesses no less!) was worse enough but to submissively spread her bare battered butt-cheeks for the kinky highschooler's perverse pleasure... Well, that would make her Dawn's bitch as much as she's Faith's bitch right now.
Surprisingly enough, this once terrifying notion didn't really bother her anymore at the moment. Instead, the thought of handing the reins of their relationship over to her sisters and letting them be in charge from now on actually appealed to her. Picturing Faith and Dawn bossing her around, something that would've seemed both ludicrous and infuriating in the past, caused her cunny to sizzle in the present.
As much as these newfound desires confused and embarrassed her, they also made her hornier than she'd ever believe possible. Which made giving in to these kinda degrading demands a whole lot easier.
Taking a deep breath, Buffy slid her fingers up her legs to her upraised ass and with each hand firmly grabbed a sore butt-cheek. Eager for her siblings' approval, she couldn't resist looking at them as she's about to humiliate herself even more. Perversely flattered by the lust and excitement she saw on their faces, she actually felt keen to give them what they wanted.
'That's it! Spread those cheeks and show them all what a hot little slayer slut you are.' Her inner voice cheered her on.
Surrendering fully to this overwhelming arousing submissiveness, the once dignified and self-assured Slayer spread herself wide open: showing off her wet swollen slit and puckered anus to her underage audience.
The three brunettes rewarded the blonde's degrading display with loud whistling and applause. Sporting a pretty blush, Buffy smiled shyly at the trio thru her wide-spread legs and even tried her best to spread her cheeks further. A surge of heat rushed to her face (and cunny) as she realized that from now on "bitch" was her new ranking in the Summers sisters' social pecking order, and would likely remain so for a long time.
"Kudos, B. That's one helluva spread," Faith said genuinely impressed while staring shamelessly into her sibling's wide-spread openings.
"Yeah, you can almost see what she had for breakfast," a giggling Janice excitedly observed.
The youngest Summers sister was unusually quiet as she stared spellbound at this lewd exhibition. It's said that reality almost never lives up to your imagination, but this was one of those rare cases were the opposite was actually true. Many times she'd fantasized about being in charge of her much admired, yet also infuriating, oldest sister and giving her a good bare-bottomed spanking, but none of those fantasies ever came close to this.
Being able to punish, degrade and dominate her once proud sister so completely was way more than she'd ever dare to dream and without a doubt the most arousing experience of her entire life, which... was rather confusing.
Despite the constant neglect and rejection Buffy had put her through over the years, she still loved her beautiful, brave big sister with all her heart. Yet at the same time she also felt an almost overwhelming urge to keep on punishing and humiliating her sanctimonious sibling till Buffy was totally bitch-tamed and would do whatever they wanted. 'For starters, move back home again, where she'd have to walk around bare-assed naked and submit to regular family spankings from now on. Heh. I bet Mom would love that as much as we do. I think she misses spanking Buffy's cute butt almost as much her actual presence at home.'
While spying on her sister's punishment sessions, Dawn not only intently studied Buffy's bare butt getting battered but also her mother's face as she vigorously spanked her eldest daughter. And judging from the gleam in Joyce's eyes and the small, satisfied smirk on her lips as she smacked her hairbrush down again and again unto the squealing blonde's jiggling buns, it was fairly obvious that their mom enjoyed the task of disciplining her bratty offspring.
'Not that I blame her 'cause the same goes for Faith and me. Our bitchy big sis is just so... supremely spankable. Hmm, too bad I only got three lashes left. Gonna make every one of 'em count, though. Oh, yeah... Buffy will remember this strapping for a looong time.'
Still gazing intently at her sister's lewdly offered openings, Dawn sighed happily. 'Thank you, Faith, for making this happen! Best. Gift. EVER.'
"Alrighty... Better give me some room, girls," the young brunette grinned as she menacingly started swinging the leather strap around above her head again.
Janice and Faith quickly scooted backwards a bit and waited with eager anticipation for the S.P.S. to strike one of the several tempting targets the naked blonde was presenting.
Buffy seemed almost hypnotized as she stared at the rapidly twirling strap with a mixture of dread and fascination. Despite having a good idea where the strap was likely to land next, she still kept herself fully spread: submissively offering up her most tender and intimate parts to her kid sister for whatever punishment she'd deemed just.
“Ooowwwwwieeee!!!” Buffy squealed as with amazing accuracy Dawn struck a particularly painful lash directly unto her delicate rosebud.
"Bullseye!" Faith cheered as she and Janice rewarded the youngest Summers' impressive marksmanship with a standing ovation.
"Thank you, thank you!" Dawn graciously said while taking a light bow. "Did I managed to impress you as well, Buffy?" she questioned with an impish smile.
"Ooohhhhh! Definitely!" Buffy groaned. The beautiful blonde comically hopped around naked from one foot to the other while still keeping her cheeks spread. "I-owww!-I think that was probably the best one yet. Pretty clever, Dawn: punishing my asshole for being an asshole."
The three brunettes laughed amazed and excited at that weirdly honest response.
"Thanks, Sis," Dawn snickered. "I'll try to do just as well on the next stroke... Ya think I'll be able to hit your cute lil bunghole again?"
"Mmmmm, I'm sure you will," Buffy moaned while bending down again as far as she could, so her backside and butthole were once more properly presented for more strict sisterly punishment.
TWACKKK!!!! "Yooooowwwwwww!!!!!!"
Sure enough, Dawn managed to land another direct hit unto her aching asshole. Even though she didn't hit much harder than before, it still hurt twice as bad—almost as if a firecracker had gone off there!—causing her to jump a good two feet in the air to the merriment of her underage audience.
"Another hole in one!" Faith laughed.
"Ouch! That looked really painful," a wide-eyed Janice observed, cringing a bit in sympathy.
"Ohhhhhhh!! It SOOO is!" Buffy gasped with tears in her eyes. "Please-please-please-PLEASE don't whip my lil bunghole again," she begged her kid sister while pouting adorably—just like she sometimes did with their mom whenever she needed a special favor.
Chuckling at this entertaining and empowering sight, Dawn magnanimously reassured Buffy that the last lash would be directed unto her pert bare buttocks and not her asshole.
"Thank you, Dawn," the tiny blonde chirped relieved.
Despite having seen plenty of evidence of her big sister's sudden surprising submissiveness, Dawn could still hardly believe her ears that Buffy actually thanked her for choosing to whip her butt cheeks instead of her butthole.
"Atta girl, B, sounds like you're finally learning how to behave," Faith said with a wink at Dawn.
Winking back, Dawn sternly told her once idolized big sister that she should show her gratitude by presenting her "cute round butt" in the best way possible for the final lash.
"O-of course, Dawn," Buffy stammered red-faced. "Just tell me how you want me."
'Heh. She already sounds bitch-tamed!'
Brimming with confidence and lust, Dawn called out, "Turn around and spread your legs, then squat down and place your hands flat on the floor while arching your back."
Witnessing Buffy's instant obedience to this degrading demand and seeing her sister assume such a humiliating pose at HER command triggered Dawn's first ever orgasm without any physical stimulation whatsoever!
Dawn had plenty of kinky thoughts about her sister before (both of them, actually), but she only now realized that she truly wanted to FUCK her. She wanted to ride her sibling's pretty face for hours upon end till it was drenched with her girl-cum; strap on a dildo and fuck Buffy's uptight ass while simultaneously spanking it good; shove her arm all the way up till the elbow inside that cute blonde-fuzzed cooch and fist-fuck her squealing sis to at least a dozen mind-blowing orgasms!
Glassy-eyed and breathing heavily, the youngest Summers gazed enthralled at the lewd presentation her once so dignified eldest sister put on for them while excitedly contemplating the multitude of perverted un-sisterly stuff she so desperately wanted to do with her.
Buffy's swollen glistening cunt-lips and puckered asshole were once again on full display in this incredibly revealing pose and none of the three brunettes were particularly shy when it came to checking out the sexy slayer's goodies.
"Look at her cunny, she looks about ready to pop!" Janice giggling observed while staring wide-eyed at the degraded college girl's sopping wet snatch. "She must REALLY like this."
"Yup, B is such-a exhibitionistic little pain-slut—always has been; she just needed a bit of help bringing it out," Faith casually declared. "Ain't that right, B?"
"Yes, Mistress Faith," Buffy timidly agreed this time.
"Such a good girl! You're definitely learning," Faith grinned excitedly. "Now I think you should -very nicely- ask Dawnie for that final lash on your naughty bare ass like a good lil pain-slut."
They looked at each other with incredulous delight as Buffy did exactly that.
"P-please Dawnie," Buffy blushingly requested. "Please give my naughty naked Buffy-butt a good, hard final beating."
"Why, it'll be my pleasure, dear sister," Dawn giggled while spinning the Summers Punishment Strap around above her head, summoning all the strength she had left for this final stroke. "Ready... Set... GO!"
WHAACCKKKK!!!! The heavy leather struck its round, firm target with such force that it actually left an indentation.
"AAAHHHHHHH!!!!" Buffy yelled as she literally jumped a good 1½ feet into the air. As much as this amused her underage audience, what the bare-naked blonde did next once again had them in stitches.
"Owe! Owe! OWIIIIEEEE!!!" the thoroughly whipped slayer cried wide-eyed as she hopped around her former bedroom for almost an entire minute, her cute pink-tipped titties bouncing jauntily as she frantically rubbed her blazing butt-cheeks.
When Buffy's frantic rubbing had finally soothed her poor mistreated posterior to a sufficient degree, she'd -accidentally yet quite appropriately- ended up kneeling on the floor in front of her smiling sisters. Still sniffling a bit and shielding her aching ass with both hands, the beaten blonde meekly gazed up at them with a mixture of trepidation and thrill.
Yes, strange though it seems, part of her was actually craving whatever humiliation her wicked siblings would think of next. Because no matter how hot her buttocks were feeling right now, the heat and need coming from her poor neglected cunny just seemed a whole lot more important.
To be continued... (hopefully a lot sooner than this chapter took)
- 4
- 5
You need to be logged in to leave a review for this story.
Report Story

Buffy's Bad Bet