Adult-FanFiction.org : Buffy

Buffy's Bad Bet	By : Oric13 Category: BtVS AU/AR > Threesomes/Moresomes Views: 54990 -:- Recommendations : 1 -:- Currently Reading : 4
Disclaimer: I do not own Buffy the Vampire Slayer (BtVS), nor any of the characters from it. I do not make any money from the writing of this story.

Chapter List
- 3
- 4
- 5
Featuring

Buffy Summers (portrayed by Sarah Michelle Gellar)

Faith (portrayed by Eliza Dushku)

Dawn Summers (portrayed by Michelle Trachtenberg)

Janice Penshaw (portrayed by Amber Tamblyn)

Chapter 4 – Buffy's continuing degradation (Fff/F, D/s, exhib, humil, mc?, oral, spank, toys, voyeur)
Sporting a huge smile, an immensely satisfied Faith surveyed the erotically charged scene in front of her: Buffy Summers—without a doubt the most stuck-up slayer of the century—completely naked and aroused on display; meekly presenting her thoroughly spanked ass, perky tits, and her juicy blonde snatch to her two sisters and a virtual stranger.
‘Un-fucking-believable! Thank you, Red, you amazingly brilliant bitch.’
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
When Willow first came to her with this crazy ploy “to teach Buffy a much needed lesson in humility”, Faith had simply smiled and nodded, figuring that at the very least it should be worth a laugh. But when the obviously very excited witch started saying things like, “turning her into our submissive slave girl”, “spanking her self-righteous ass” and “making her go down on us”, she kinda figured that the redhead had gone off the deep end, right into la-la land. “Never gonna work, Red. B’s not gonna do any of that, no matter how many bets she loses.”
But Wills, however, stubbornly insisted that it WOULD work. Buffy would do all these things and MORE. She was certain of it ‘cause she’d taken these psych classes, which helped her figure out that Buffy had this deeply rooted submissive side, and by using the right triggers they could… blah-blah-blabbity-blah… It all seemed like a bunch of mumbo jumbo to me.
Yeah, sure, Red's a very clever girl, and I know I’m not exactly college material myself, but I seriously doubt that taking a few psych classes suddenly enables you to pull this kinda Jedi mind shit on people, especially stubborn little blondes like B.
Which is why I had no problem making a bet on the side with Red regarding the success of her kooky lil scheme. Hell, I wasn’t even worried when she negotiated some pretty kinky demands if we did somehow managed to pull this off.
During a girls night out a while back (which, of course, B had ditched to be with her farmboytoy), Red had (hilariously) shocked her girlfriend by drunkenly confessing her secret fantasy to one day treat her arrogant, former BFF’s cute bubble butt to a good, hard spanking & screwing. So I wasn’t really surprised when the first thing she demanded was B’s anal cherry.
Secondly, because I’d dared to doubt her perfect plan, she’d get to spank and fuck MY ass as well if it succeeds (Damn, that girl collects grudges like freakin' stamps!).
And thirdly, though we’d share “ownership”, Red would be in charge of B’s taming-slash-bitch training and I had to give her my full cooperation, which (for some reason) also includes me dressing exactly how she wants during our “sessions” with B.
So, confident that this wasn’t gonna work in a million years, I literally put our asses on the line, and then some… My demand that she’d hafta streak naked thru UC SunnyD’s campus during the busiest part of the day if she loses, seemed kinda tame in comparison.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Well, despite havin’ to endure some humiliation herself as punishment for doubting her wicked witchy friend, this was one bet that Faith didn’t mind losing. It’s worth it for the opportunity alone to spank the living daylights out of B’s sweet, stuck-up ass.
A smirk formed on the dark slayer’s lips as she studied big sis’ oh-so-spankable butt, still meekly presented in the perfect punishment pose by the surprisingly submissive blonde. Her mind was practically bursting with all kindsa sexy scenarios for her beautiful bitch to star in, starting with a really fun way to make this second spanking even more humiliating than the first. ‘Heh. Can’t wait to see the look on B’s face when she finds out what’s up next.’
Standing up, Faith quickly pushed her chair back under the desk before sauntering over to the two tittering teens, who were still intently studying the blushing blonde’s exposed charms, and put her arms around them in a comradely manner. “You know, girls, I’m thinking that it would be selfish of me to keep B’s cute ass all to myself. So how ‘bout you two take a crack at it—twenty-five spanks each!” she generously offered while covertly eying her slave girl’s reaction.
‘Bullseye! B couldn’t have looked more freaked even if Principal Ferret-face himself had suddenly returned from the dead to spank her.’
Not surprisingly, it was a big hit with the two teen voyeurs as well.
“Seriously?” Dawn breathlessly questioned, her cute pretty face displaying a wondrous delight. When Faith smiled and nodded, the youngest Summers sister hugged her adoptive sibling as tightly as she could, squealing, “ThankyouthankyouTHANKYOU!!!”
She was joined in her “Thank you!” chorus by Janice who, after doing an adorable dorky dance of joy around them, joined the hug.
“You’re welcome, bitches,” Faith laughed while warmly hugging the two happy brunettes back.
Feeling utterly overwhelmed by the veritable avalanche of humiliation that had befallen her in such a short time, Buffy stared dazedly up through her wide-spread legs at the two jubilant teens who acted like they just won a million bucks. Especially Dawnie seemed freakin’ ecstatic about the chance to spank her… In fact, given the choice between a million dollars or the opportunity to punish and humiliate her much-envied big sister, she wouldn’t be surprised if Dawn picked the latter.
‘So now I’m actually gonna get a bare assed spanking from my kid sister and her friend as well?’
Buffy suddenly realized that if she’d allow this to happen then Dawn would forever have the upper-hand in their relationship, as her bratty sibling would undoubtedly rub it in her face at every opportunity. Whatever future argument they’d have, Dawn could easily shut her up by saying something like, “Better watch it, Sis, or I’m gonna have to spank your naughty bare bottom again.”
This horrifying notion shocked her out of the submissive spiral she was in.
“NO!” she suddenly called out, rudely disrupting this very special Hallmark hugging moment. Snapping upright and closing her legs, the tiny slayer turned to confront her temporary owner. “No. Freakin’. Way! I’m NOT letting my kid sister spank me.”
Even though most people would pretty much react this way when told they’re about to be spanked by their little sister, Faith seemed surprised by Buffy’s outburst.
“Listen, B, you’re my slave girl, which means th--”
“I might be your slave girl for now, but not my kid sister’s,” Buffy abruptly cut her off. “So Dawn doesn’t get to spank me, and neither does Janice,” she added.
This obviously put a damper on the high school girls’ spirits. “Party-pooper!” Dawn pouted. She and Janice looked at Faith for support, hoping she’d swiftly put her impudent slave girl in her place and make Buffy present her cute bare bottom for a spanking again.
But for the first time since claiming her sexy blonde prize, Faith seemed somewhat at a loss as she gazed befuddled at a very naked, but also very determined looking, Buffy Summers. You could almost see the wheels turning in her head as she frantically tried to think of a way to handle this situation without it (and Buffy) blowing up in her face.
‘The most important trigger is Buffy’s slave collar & ownership tag, which symbolizes her lowly status of a slave girl and also works as a constant reminder of her inner desire to submit,’ Faith recalled Willow’s instructions. ‘So it’s an absolute key factor in our plan that you get her to wear it. Once she does, and you handle her exactly like I said, everything should go as planned… But just in case it doesn’t and she decides to rebel, try to focus Buffy’s attention on the ownership tag. That should remind her that she’s my—I mean your lil slave slut now.’
“Doesn’t sound like you fully grasp the definition of “slave girl”, B,” Faith finally said after several long seconds of hushed silence. “So here’s a lil reminder: it means you hafta to OBEY me, as in doin’ whatever I desire,” she added with a husky voice as she stepped closer to her slayer slave till they were standing only inches apart.
“Whatever,” Buffy scoffed, trying to ignore the beautiful brunette’s warm breath caressing her naked skin. “You’re taking this all WAY too literally. I’m not really your slave girl! It’s just some silly little bet I lost—you didn’t buy me at a freakin’ slave market.”
“That silly little bet and you swearing to abide by it is all that’s needed to make you my slave girl, sweet cheeks.” Faith grinned impudently as she gradually regained her confidence. “Just check out your collar and the shiny ownership tag hanging from it.” Grabbing the silver dog tag, the brunette pulled it towards her and into Buffy’s field of vision, causing her to glance down instinctively.
“See?” Faith spoke seductively in her sister slayer’s ear as the blonde stared intently at the gleaming metal. “It has your name on it, and it says… Well, you know what it says, don’t ya, B?”
“Buffy the Slave-Bitch,” Buffy whispered, suddenly looking a lot less sure of herself.
“Exactly!” Faith happily confirmed with a wicked grin on her face while giving the once again hopeful looking teens a conspiring little wink. “Which means you’re MINE, and if I wanna give someone a go at your cute round ass that's MY business.”
‘That just CAN’T be right?!’ But no matter how absurd it seemed, the brunette’s logic somehow appeared watertight.
“But… that’s not fair,” Buffy weakly objected while desperately trying to recall some of the arguments to support her case that seemed so obvious earlier.
“Not fair?” Faith mockingly repeated. “What are you, six? Nobody forced you to take the bet, B. It was your own call.”
“But there was nothing in the conditions of that bet about me getting spanked by Dawn!” Buffy tried again, desperately searching for the right words to express the obvious unfairness of it all. ‘Am I really the only one who can see how very wrong this is?!’
Judging from the big smirks on the other girls’ faces, it certainly seemed that way.
“So what? You should be glad I’m lettin’ Dawn and Janice deliver your final fifty spanks—I’m actually doing you a solid,” Faith managed to say with a straight face.
Buffy’s mouth fell open. “What?! How is that doing me a solid?!”
“You should know by now how hard I can hit, B,” Faith said, and instantly reminded her by delivering a full force slayer strength spank unto her unsuspecting sister’s bare bottom.
“Yowwwwww!!!” squealed a wide-eyed Buffy, doing a little bunny-hop while instinctively grabbing her aching buttocks, which resulted in another gigglefest from the avidly watching teens.
The tiny blonde’s reaction was so freakin’ adorable that even Faith giggled uncharacteristically. “Remember NOW? I kindly figured that you’d prefer fifty spanks from them instead of fifty spanks from me. But since you decided to act like a lil ingrate about it, I’m not sure I should be letting you off so easy anymore.”
“No, please! I’m sorry for being… ungrateful, Ma’am,” Buffy hurriedly apologized, every bit of defiance now gone as she meekly rubbed her sore behind. The beaten slayer anxiously bit down on her lower lip as she realized that some kind of humbling gesture might be necessary to appease the annoyed brunette. And, looking at the two giggling high school girls, she instantly thought of something that would surely thrill her temporarily owner.
‘Best to just get it over with, I guess, before Faith comes up with something even more humiliating for me.’
Having made up her mind, the red-faced blonde spread her legs several feet apart and grabbed a hold of her ankles, once again presenting her well-spanked ass, wet swollen cunny-lips, and perky pink-tipped tits to her appreciative audience—only this time without any prompting from her “Mistress”.
“Dawn, Janice,” Buffy shyly addressed the bright-eyed teens thru her obscenely wide-spread legs. “I-I’m sorry for refusing to accept my proper punishment before, p-please give my n-naughty bare behind a good spanking.”
“ALRIGHT!!!” Dawn loudly cheered, jumping up and pumping her fist in the air like some fanatic football fan whose team finally won their first Superbowl. “I finally get to spank Buffy’s bare butt!” she jubilantly cried out, her radiant eyes fixed unto her big sister’s invitingly upraised, round blushing buttocks.
The overjoyed teenager grabbed her equally excited friend and did a little dance around the blushing bend-over blonde while cheerfully singing, “I’m gonna spank Buffy’s bare butt!”
“I’m gonna spank Buffy’s bare butt as well!” Janice happily joined in.
“I already spanked Buffy’s bare butt,” Faith dryly noted in a sing-song voice once they finished, bringing forth another burst of giggles from the teens.
Though cringing her way throughout this latest bout of humiliation, Buffy was actually more fixated on her Mistress than the teasing teens. Still anxious about Faith’s threat for more punishment, she hoped that presenting her private parts to those little brats and begging ‘em for a spanking would be enough to please the kinky Bostonian. ‘Well, judging from the huge smile on her face, I’m probably good.’
Filled with pride at not only having won this battle of wills with her sister slayer, but also somehow managing to convince the blonde to further degrade herself, Faith felt very pleased indeed. ‘This went even better than I’d hoped!’
“Now that’s more like it, B,” Faith said, putting on her “strict Dominatrix” face as she gave the humbled blonde an approving little nod, “but there better be no more lip from you,” she sternly warned, “or you’ll be havin' a session with the Summers Punishment Strap for sure.”
“What’s this “Summers Punishment Strap”?” Janice questioned intrigued. “I remember you mentioning it before.”
The Summers sisters exchanged a sheepish look. After a moment of hesitation, Dawn decided to share this embarrassing family secret with her friend. “It’s this heavy leather strap which has been in the family for generations, and is used solely for corporal punishment.”
Janice smiled amazed. “So what you’re saying is that you have this ancient heirloom specifically intended to whip the naked hineys of naughty children. That’s, like, sooo precious!”
‘Not really,’ Buffy thought desponded, as she recalled the times her own naughty, naked hiney had an intimate encounter with the Summers Punishment Strap.
“I think B probably disagrees with that,” Faith grinned, as if reading Buffy’s mind.
“Kinda surprised, though, that in this day and age it’s still being used in your family.”
“Well, actually Dad wanted to get rid off it, but Mom decided to hold onto it to keep us inline, threatening to someday use it on our bare butts if we ever did something really, REALLY bad.” Dawn explained, “And whaddaya know, she finally got some use out of it after Buffy burned down the gym at her old school, and again when Lil Miss Pyromania burned all the photos she could find that pictured her as a brunette.”
“So your mom has only used the infamous Summers Punishment Strap on your sister’s cute round ass?” a now completely captivated Janice questioned; her BFF had such a fascinating family!
“Well, until recently,” Dawn wryly replied. “Unfortunately, MY cute round ass also received a lengthy session with it after big sis kindly informed mom about me blowing my big black boyfriend in the locker room.”
“Heh, guess I’m truly a Summers girl then ‘cause my sweet ass also got a formal introduction to the S.P.S,” Faith confessed with a surprising amount of cheer.
“For reals?” Janice exclaimed while directing a fascinated stare at Faith’s firm leather-clad buns.
“When did this happen?” an equally enthralled Dawn inquired, her eyes focused on the same tempting target as her friend.
“Right before I moved in here. Joyce told me I still needed to be properly punished for all the shit I’d pulled, and I pretty much agreed,” the dark slayer nonchalantly explained. “So she had me strip buck-naked, grab my ankles, and then whooped my ass good with that heavy leather strap.”
“Mistress Joyce,” Janice excitedly snickered as she pictured a completely naked Buffy, Dawn and Faith lined up and bending over while their MILFy mom whipped their naughty behinds.
“Yeah, “Mistress Joyce” sounds about right,” Faith grinned. “That lady sure knows how to handle bad girls.”
“Mom really made you strip completely naked for the whipping?” Dawn questioned intrigued.
Faith shot the inquisitive teen a bright smile; she was hoping for an opportunity to further expand on this. “Mmm-mm, she sure did,” the dark slayer said with a deliberate husky voice. “And when my future mommy told me to strip, I decided to have a little fun. So I put on some tunes and started doin’ a sexy striptease for her, just to see how she’d handle it. I figured at the very least I’d make her blush, but she stayed cool as a cucumber. Didn’t even blink when I practically shoved my naked knockers in her face, and seductively whispered in her ear, “Whaddaya think of my titties, Mrs. S?”.”
“You didn’t!” Dawn gasped amazed.
“Oh, wow! How did she react to that?” Janice eagerly inquired.
“While sipping her wine, she calmly checked out my tatas and said: “They’re spectacular, Faith.”,” the brunette proudly declared.
“No way!” Buffy called out, so annoyed by Faith’s preposterous claim that she momentarily forgot to act properly subservient like a good slave girl.
“Yes way,” Faith calmly replied. With a mischievous gleam in her eyes, the busty brunette suddenly yanked up her shirt, proudly revealing her braless perky melons! And then sexily bounced ‘em around a bit for good measure.
“See? They ARE spectacular,” she grinned before pulling her shirt down again.
“Damn!” a wide-eyed Janice gasped. Dawn just grinned; she’d already seen those spectacular tatas many times before.
“That’s not—I mean… I meant that mom would never say that,” the blushing blonde finally managed to express while trying to stop herself from staring any longer at the dark slayer’s admittedly fabulous rack.
“Tsk, you just don’t learn, do ya, B?” Faith said with a teasing smirk. “Callin’ me a liar instead of Mistress or Ma’am. Hmm-mm-mm-mm… now what did I say would happen if ya gave me anymore lip?”
“A session with the Summers Punishment Strap!” Dawn practically cheered, her eyes sparkling with excitement as she stared intently at her naked, bend over, sheepish-looking sibling.
“That’s right, D, I DID say that. So I guess instead of fifty spanks, you’ll be getting fifty lashes from the S.P.S. on your naughty, naked hiney, B.”
“Ouch! Sucks to be you, right now,” Janice commented with a cheeky grin, making the other two brunettes snicker.
Buffy’s mouth opened and closed, yet not a word came out as the wide-eyed blonde stared dumbfounded at her smirking sisters. It took some time till her befuddled brain was finally able to put together a meek protest, “B-but, Ma’am, that’s not fair. Surely a bare-bottomed spanking from Dawn and Janice is already punishment enough?”
“It was, till you opened your big mouth, B,” Faith countered with a teasing smile. “I did warn ya, right?
“Well, yes, I guess so, but I—”
Before she could finish her sentence, Buffy’s red, upraised ass was suddenly treated to yet another surprise slayer-strength spank.
SMACKKK!!! “Ouch!!”
“Ma’am or Mistress, you naughty girl,” Faith practically purred while possessively squeezing the firm yet supple butt-cheek she just slapped. “And don’t ya forget it.”
“Sorry, Ma’am,” Buffy blushingly apologized. Calling the former rogue slayer “Ma’am” or “Mistress” definitely took some getting used to, but she’d better learn quickly if she didn’t want to give Faith anymore excuses to punish her. Luckily, her adoptive sister didn’t seem particularly upset about this latest slip up. Probably because she was preoccupied with checking out her cunny, which, for some reason Buffy couldn’t quite comprehend, was wetter than ever before.
Having her embarrassingly aroused pussy so blatantly checked out was mortifying enough for the naughty, naked blonde, but Faith wouldn’t be Faith if she didn’t come up with some way to increase the kink factor.
Smoothly squatting down, which pretty much placed Faith's face just inches from her sister slayer's spread snatch, the kinky Bostonian grabbed a hold of her other buttock as well and casually pried them apart with her strong hands, utterly revealing not just her overly aroused cunny but also her tiny puckered anus to the three brunettes’ eager eyes.
Letting out a mortifying squeak, Buffy seriously considered that right this moment she’d might literally DIE of humiliation. Up till now, the wee blonde’s embarrassing squeals never failed to trigger a burst of laughter from her giddy schoolgirl audience, but this time the only sound they made was a stunned “Whoa!” followed by a long, pregnant silence.
‘This isn’t really happening!’ an almost hyperventilating Buffy frantically thought. ‘No way would I actually be bending over buck-naked, presenting my pussy and asshole to both my sisters and Dawn’s cute friend. This must be a dream—a really vivid feverish dream. Yup, absolutely. I’m gonna close my eyes, and when I open them, I’ll be safely in my bed.’
Tightly closing her eyes, Buffy kept them shut for almost a minute while visualizing herself waking up in her bed. The only problem was that she could still feel Faith’s hands holding her buttcheeks apart. ‘You’re just imagining that,’ she reassured herself. ‘You’re definitely just dreaming this!’
Carefully Buffy opened her eyes, hoping that all she would see was the inside of her dark dorm room. Instead she found herself faced with not just one, but, count ‘em: THREE teenaged girls less than a foot away, their excited eyes peering intently inside her wide-spread openings.
Apparently, after Buffy shut her eyes, Dawn and Janice had both decided to come in for a closer look. Cuddled up on either side against the beautiful Bostonian with their arms around each other while resting their heads on the dark slayer’s strong shoulders would’ve made for a heartwarming tableau under different circumstances. But considering the underage teens were gazing with perverted interest straight into Buffy’s juicy pink pussy & asshole, heartwarming definitely wasn’t the right word for it.
“This is SO fuckin’ HOT!” a pink-cheeked Janice exclaimed before hungrily slurping on her lollypop in an almost pornographic manner.
Dawn just nodded, seemingly spellbound as she inspected her oldest sister’s wet, widespread snatch with unsettling intensity.
Profoundly disturbing was more like it! But to Buffy’s dismay, the schoolgirls lustful stares actually made her exposed cunny even more aroused.
“Wow, ya sure are one kinky lil slave bitch, B,” Faith observed with an impish smile while winking at the bend-over blonde, whose face couldn’t possibly get any redder.
“Yeah, who’d a thunk that my uptight, self-righteous big sister Buffy would turn out to be such an exhibitionistic lil perv,” a smirking Dawn happily piled on.
It wasn’t that long ago that Buffy was trying her hardest to get out of a spanking from her little sister, but right now she’d rather let Dawn whip her bare butt a hundred times with the Summers Punishment Strap than be subjected a minute longer to this excruciating humiliation.
“I-I am not an exhibitionistic lil perv,” Buffy meekly objected, sniffling a little as a tear or two threatened to drip from her eyes.
“Well, you’re definitely not BIG,” Janice giggled. “What are you, like five feet tall?”
“I’m like half a feet taller than that!” Buffy objected, a lot stronger now. Her height had always been a sensitive topic for her. “And I’m only a little bit shorter than Faith.”
“You’re still the shortest one in the room,” Faith smirked.
“And not only are you the shortest Summers girl, you're also the one with the smallest tits,” Dawn teased.
“No, I'm not,” Buffy blushingly protested. With uncanny accuracy, her youngest sister had managed to pinpoint yet another thing she felt insecure about.
“Yes, you are,” Dawn and Faith said in unison.
“Am not!” Buffy squeaked, even though she knew her sisters were right.
Faith and Dawn looked at each other. Exchanging a grin they both pulled up their shirts and smugly presented their ample C cups to Buffy and Janice.
“Judge Janice, how doest thou rule?” a grinning Dawn questioned.
“Definitely bigger,” Janice grinned back, feeling a twinge of jealousy as she mentally compared them with her own much more modest A cups. Her BFF sure had some nice titties and she loved it when Dawn decided to show them off.
“She’s hardly an impartial judge,” Buffy still tried, unable to help herself.
Dawn rolled her eyes, but then a mischievous grin appeared on her face. “Well, check for yourself then.” Leaning down, Dawn grabbed the back of her sister’s head and pulled Buffy’s comically thunderstruck face smack-dab into her cleavage. Shimmying her luscious twins around, the young brunette slapped them repeatedly against her big sister’s brightly blushing cheeks before finally releasing the bewildered blonde.
Faith and Janice were laughing so hard they both had tears in their eyes.
“Alrighty, guess I’m up next for “Who’s got the Biggest Funbags”,” Faith laughed as Dawn scooted backwards and she in turn leaned towards Buffy, whose upside-down face gazed at the next set of approaching mammaries with a slack-jawed, wide-eyed expression.
The submissive slayer was once again pulled into a firm couple of C cups, which were rubbed and smacked unto every inch of her beet-red face. Only this time it wasn’t just the involuntary motorboating of her sister’s boobs that made Buffy blush.
Leaning down the way she was, Faith’s nose grazed repeatedly against Buffy’s sore buttocks and she could also feel the brunette’s warm breath caressing her aroused pussy. At first this all seemed rather accidental, but suddenly that nose dipped between her cheeks and rubbed up against her sensitive rosebud. At the same time, Faith’s raspy tongue swiftly lapped back and forth across her swollen pussy lips a few times before teasingly flicking her stiff little clit. Aroused as she already was, this was almost enough to make her cum on the spot.
Buffy’s gasp of pleasure was partially muffled by the voluptuous tit-flesh enveloping her face, but she still worried that she may have alerted their underage audience to this latest outrageous development. ‘I can’t believe Faith practically went down on me in front of them!’ Although considering all the other kinky shit her sister slayer had pulled thus far, this really shouldn’t surprise her.
“So whaddaya say now, B?” Faith impishly questioned the panting, glassy eyed blonde after teasing her to the brink of an orgasm no less than three times while nearly smothering her with her boobs.
“OK, fine, so you’re both bigger than me,” Buffy answered despondently. “But I’m NOT an exhibitionistic perv.”
“She says while bend over completely naked and showing us her soaking wet snatch,” Dawn mockingly noted.
This time Buffy couldn’t think of any defense, because there was really no way to deny her obvious arousal. And she also couldn’t hold back her tears of shame any longer. ‘Oh great, now I’m also crying like a little bitch in front of them.’
“Awww, it’s okay, Buffy,” Dawn comforted her big sister. “I’d much rather have an exhibitionistic lil perv for a sister than the uptight, self-righteous princess I always thought you were.”
“That’s right, B,” Faith chimed in. “We’re your sisters and we love you no matter what, so don’t be afraid to be your slutty self around us.”
“B-but I’m really not a s-slut,” Buffy sniffled, though it kinda felt like she needed to convince herself of that right now.
“Try telling that to your sopping wet slit, sis,” Dawn chuckled with Janice and Faith snickering along.
“You know, in her current position she kinda IS telling it to her dripping wet slit,” Janice keenly observed. “Its, like, only an inch or five from her face.”
Faith thoughtfully nodded. “Yeah, hafta admit that B is pretty fuckin’ bendable… With a bit of practice she might even be able to go down on herself.”
There was another, long pregnant pause as the three brunettes gazed intrigued at the bend over, beet-red blonde as they mulled this exciting concept over.
Buffy couldn’t take it any longer. It seemed like she’d been bend over, naked and vulnerable for hours now! Suffering constant shame and humiliation while awaiting some embarrassing punishment. She no longer really cared anymore about her kid sister spanking, or even whipping, her ass. At this point, she just wanted to get it over with. ‘But Faith is obviously trying to drag this out for as long as she possibly can, so that means… I’ll have to take the initiative for my very own ass-whipping.’
“I give!” Buffy blushingly called out, breaking the silence. Taking a deep breath, she reluctantly went on, “Dawn, Janice, I-I hereby humbly offer you my naughty bare bottom for a good, hard whipping with the Summers Punishment Strap.”
These humiliating words had their intended effect on the two teens.
“Yay!” Janice cheered, clapping her hands with glee.
“Lets go find that strap so Janice and I can start whipping Buffy’s slutty ass,” Dawn eagerly suggested to a rather bemused looking Faith. Giving her big sister’s invitingly upraised rump a final, hungry look, the youngest Summers grabbed her adopted sister’s hand and practically dragged her with in search of the infamous Summers Punishment Strap.
Despite still being very much naked in a degrading pose and increasingly closer to receiving one helluva butt-whipping, Buffy breathed a sigh of relief as her siblings left the room. Ever since Faith had “won” their bet, it seemed like she’d been on this twisted rollercoaster ride driving her to ever-increasing highs of humiliation & arousal without having any time to think. Maybe now that her kinky sisters were gone, she’d be able to clear her head. Because something definitely felt “off” about this entire situation.
Although something also felt “on”, namely Janice's hand on her ass... which, despite everything, still kinda took Buffy by surprise. Though apparently quite the voyeuristic lil vixen, the cute freshman just didn't seem like a dominant, take charge kinda gal... But then what high schooler did. Apparently she underestimated the young brunette.
Buffy hadn’t really paid much attention to her sister’s BFF before (too busy fighting evil and all that), but she did notice that Janice was very pretty. However, studying her from up close like this, Buffy realized that pretty was actually kind of an understatement: Janice Penshaw had movie star-like good looks and a tight little body to match her beautiful face. And the auburn-haired hottie certainly wasn’t shy when it came to showing off her sexy form: casually wearing a belly bearing halter top coupled with an almost indecent short skirt that splendidly showed off the teen’s long slender legs. Also, despite her tender age, Miss Penshaw was wearing a set of high-heeled brown suede Prada boots which were almost as awesome as the black leather beauties she herself was instructed to wear tonight.
‘Damn! I can’t believe Janice’s mom would let her fourteen year old daughter wear something so sexy,’ Buffy thought with a touch of resentment as she recalled the embarrassing bare-bottomed spanking she got from her own mom for wearing a similar outfit at the practically adult age of seventeen.
At the moment, however, there was more pressing stuff to think about… like the look of lust on Dawnie’s cute friend’s face as the fourteen year old inspected her naked body. Janice’s intense visual examination made Buffy once again hyper aware of the lewd, degrading pose she's still in, even though her "Mistress" was gone now. 'So why the Hell am I still bend over with my sopping wet snatch on display?'
Shaking her head in disbelief at her own submissive sluttiness, the debased slayer started to straighten till Janice suddenly stopped her with a slap on the ass and a sternly voiced, "Hold your position!"
Several hours of being Faith's bitch had obviously made a quite an impression on Buffy's psyche, at least enough to automatically obey the high schoolgirl's insolent command and meekly reassume her wide-spread bend over pose.
"That's a good girl," Janice purred. "I just can't get enough of seeing you like this, Buffy. I've been crushing on you for like a year now," the excited teen breathlessly confessed while her hands possessively roamed all over the older girl's exquisite naked form, "but I never thought I'd actually get to see you naked, let alone play with your naughty bits!"
And... that's exactly what she then did. Impudently grabbing Buffy's dangling B-cups with both hands, Janice started stroking and squeezing 'em, bestowing special attention unto the blonde's sensitive hard pink nips.
To say that Buffy was shocked would be an understatement. Once again, she tried to make sense of the situation but it was like her brain was on strike or something. And it didn't help that part of her was thoroughly enjoying the wonderful sensations coming from her titties.
'So now you're letting Janice feel you up as well?!' This indignant question resonated in Buffy befuddled brain as Janice's funbag fondling gradually approached the one minute mark without so much as a "Hands off, bitch!" from her.
The truth is: she didn't really know why she's allowing Dawn's friend to grope her. Just like she didn't quite get why she'd let Faith take things this far.
However, what Buffy DID know was that all the humiliation she endured in the last few hours had brought her to entire new levels of arousal. And despite many times thinking she couldn't possibly get any more turned on, she was proven wrong again and again.
Due to all that build-up, she never needed an orgasm more badly in her entire life than she did right now. And Janice's expert handling of her boobies would definitely get her there. So, with her clitty overriding both her moral compass and her better judgment, Buffy obediently held her demeaning pose—meekly allowing the kinky teenager to have her way with her.
The slayer was a bit startled when the young brunette suddenly knelt down and initiated eye contact. Judging from the mischievous sparkle in those big brown eyes, the lovely Miss Penshaw was definitely up to something.
Reluctantly releasing the blonde's left boob, Janice swiftly slipped her hand inside her purse and pulled out another one of those ridiculously phallic-shaped lollipops, then—using only that one hand—handily unwrapped it without even breaking eye contact.
Innocently batting her eye-lashes at Buffy, the sexy teen started lustfully licking her bubblegum-flavored lolly as if she were auditioning for a remake of Lolita. Having ensured the older girl's undivided attention, Janice performed a brief but remarkable inventive blowjob on the cock-shaped candy while the wide-eyed blonde watched on.
Slowly pulling the unicorn lollipop from between her puckered lips, Janice teasingly waved it in front of Buffy’s enthralled face. Then, with a wicked smile, she aimed the long, hard lollipop at the glistening entrance of the older girl’s juicy twat and slowly slid all seven inches of the sticky, delicious candy inside.
Bend over the way she was, with her head practically between her wide-spread legs, Buffy certainly had an excellent view of her pussy being penetrated by the dildo-shaped candy. 'I've got a lollipop up my cunny,' she dreamily contemplated with a mixture of wonder and ever increasing arousal, almost giggling aloud at the weird absurdity of it all.
“I’m fucking you, Buffy,” Janice stated in a sing-song voice, immensely satisfied at her sexual supremacy over this gorgeous young woman. “I’m fucking your pretty pink pussy with my hard candy cock.”
To further emphasize her dominance, the depraved 14-year-old started spanking the blushing blonde’s butt-cheeks while thrusting and twisting the lengthy lollipop deep inside Buffy’s dripping wet box, making the shamed slayer grunt loudly in response.
“Yeah, you like that, dontcha bitch!” Janice growled excitedly as she happily fucked and spanked her BFF’s five year older stunning sister.
“Y-yes, Ma’am,” a humbled & horny Buffy moaned, causing the twisted teen to titter with delight.
SMACK! "OooOOH!!" Buffy gasped as Janice unexpectedly slapped her right titty, causing the firm flesh to wildly bounce and jiggle around. And since the timid blonde didn't even object to that, the smirking schoolgirl then slapped the other tit as well.
Smiling triumphantly, Janice alternately spanked Buffy's butt-cheeks and boobs while fucking her increasingly faster with her lollipop dildo. "You're such a submissive little slut," she gleefully observed with a touch of awe.
This time Buffy didn't bother protesting. So easily sexually dominated by this kinky high school girl it was now painfully obvious to her that she's indeed a submissive little slut. But she no longer cared; right now she just wanted to cum.
Sensing the older girl’s rapidly approaching climax, Janice abruptly withdrew her candy shlong from the blonde’s sopping wet snatch, making her mewl in frustration.
The sexually frustrated slayer gazed longingly at the glistening phallus-shaped lollipop; she was so damn horny that it took every bit of self control she possessed to keep from begging Dawn’s friend to fuck her.
‘I’ve humiliated myself enough already,’ Buffy firmly decided. Although her newfound determination already wavered when the sexy lil Lolita raised the pussy-juice coated lollipop to her lips and sensually licked it while gazing seductively into her eyes.
“Mmmm, yummy,” Janice said while lustfully smacking her lips.
Buffy watched amazed and aroused as the hot young tramp then proceeded to slide the entire 7-inches into her mouth, effectively deepthroating the pussy flavored candy. Winking impishly, Janice started raising her short skirt while rhythmically thrusting the lollipop down her throat.
Her eyes swiftly switching back and forth between Janice's slutty blowjob exhibition and the sexy teen’s slowly lifting skirt, Buffy’s mouth fell open when she suddenly found herself staring straight at Janice’s bald snatch – the little tease wasn’t even wearing so much as a thong and didn’t have a single hair there! Staring spellbound at Dawnie’s BFF’s tight little slit, she watched with bated breath as the kinky high school freshman slid the cock-shaped candy from her mouth and positioned it at the entrance of her pussy.
Slowly the teen's swollen labia-lips parted as Janice pressed the sticky lollipop into her glistening pink pussy hole. Apparently not a virgin, the horny schoolgirl didn't pause for even a single second as she shoved the hard candy cock deeper and deeper until its entire length was buried snugly inside her teenage twat.
Moaning happily, Janice fucked herself for about a minute before pulling the shiny lollipop dildo from her pussy. With a tiny smirk on her face, the young brunette silently offered it up to Buffy's face.
Cutely wrinkling her nose at the gleaming dick-shaped candy, Buffy kept her lips tightly shut, sensing that this was yet another line she shouldn't be crossing.
"You better suck my cock if you wanna cum... biatch!" Janice mischievously said with an exaggerated ghetto accent while rubbing the sticky candy against the older girl's lips.
Sighing in defeat, Buffy parted her lips and obediently swallowed every inch of the lollipop cock that Janice gleefully fed to her. She needed to cum so badly that one more degrading act suddenly didn't seem like such a big deal anymore.
"That's it! Suck my dick, bitch," Janice excitedly cheered her on. "God! You look so sexy, sucking on my big hard candy cock, Buffy. I really wish I'd brought a camera so I could have some pics of Dawnie's big tough sister debasing herself like this."
That there's no photographic evidence of her shameful, slutty behavior was the one bright spot of this entire depraved mess, Buffy considered with a small measure of relieve.
"So how do you like the taste of my pussy?" Janice teasingly inquired.
Buffy actually took a moment to consider this. Not that long ago, even the thought of going down on another girl pretty much made her gag. Hell, she never even wanted to taste her own love juices. But now that's she actually tasting another girl's cunny... Well, that she's sucking it off a lollipop probably helped, but the teen's pussy-juice tasted surprisingly sweet.
"You like it, don't you, bitch?" Janice prodded her with gleaming eyes while giving the blonde's dangling titties a couple more slaps for good measure. "I bet you even secretly love it."
Blushing prettily, Buffy shyly avoided the domineering teen's penetrating gaze. But apparently Janice actually wanted an answer.
"Say it!" Roughly pinching and pulling the submissive college girl's right nipple till the perky breast was stretched into a cone-like shape, Janice demanded, "Admit that you love my juicy teen pussy." The brunette's beautiful face was flushed with excitement as she sexually bullied the older and stronger sexy blonde.
"Yes, Ma'am!" Buffy hurriedly gave in, finding it increasingly easier to simply submit. "I love the taste of your juicy teen pussy!"
Pulling her lollipop prick from Buffy's mouth, Janice stuck it back inside her own pussy. "Well, in that case I'll treat you to a fresh coating," she laughed. "Or... maybe you'd rather lick it straight from the source this time?" the teen impishly questioned as she used two fingers to shamelessly spread her pussy-lips wide apart, treating Buffy to an unobstructed view of the brightly colored unicorn lollipop penetrating her pink pussy hole.
The aroused slayer stared wide-eyed at the young brunette's exhibitionistic display while fighting an almost irresistible urge to shove some fingers up her snatch and diddle herself to a much-needed orgasm. 'Damn, Janice might be an even bigger slut than Dawnie. What is it with teen girls these days?!' she thought amazed. Then cringed when she realized that she'd been acting like a bigger slut than both of the promiscuous high schoolers put together. In fact, weirdly enough, despite being very much straight, part of her was actually seriously considering the teen's salacious offer!
It's not like she's into girls all of a sudden, but she IS a college babe now and so it's practically expected of her that she tries some girl-on-girl stuff. Point in case: even mousy lil Willow is doing some lesbo experimenting! So why not her? And why not with this slutty twisted gorgeous teen who was literally offering her bald cunny to her?
OK, sure, there IS the small matter of Janice being total jailbait and Dawnie's BFF, but, truthfully, this also made the whole thing that much kinkier and exciting.
"Go on, Buffy," Janice panted excitedly as she fucked herself faster with her lollipop dildo, "eat my sweet lil pussy. I'll make you cum real good if you do."
Staring spellbound at the seductive spread the sexy schoolgirl was presenting, Buffy anxiously licked her lips and inched closer. 'Well, if that's what it takes to finally get some release...' she reasoned.
Her overwhelming lust had almost won over her common sense when she suddenly heard voices approaching in the hallway. Faith and Dawn were coming back!
The two brunettes practically stormed into the room, brimming with energy and sporting big grins. It had taken them a while, but they'd finally found what they were looking for. Triumphantly brandishing the infamous Summers Punishment Strap above her head, Dawn shot her naked, bend-over, big sister a menacing smirk.

To be continued...
- 3
- 4
- 5
You need to be logged in to leave a review for this story.
Report Story

Buffy's Bad Bet