Adult-FanFiction.org : Buffy

Gehanna	By : MTLandLL Category: -Buffy the Vampire Slayer > FemmeSlash - Female/Female Views: 129025 -:- Recommendations : 3 -:- Currently Reading : 2
Disclaimer: We do not own BtVS, its characters or any of the other characters that appear in this story, they belong to others. We are not making any money from this story.

Chapter List
- 1-Gehanna
- 2-2
- 3-3
- 4-4
- 5-5
- 6-6
- 7-7
- 8-8
- 9-9
- 10-10
- 11-11
- 12-12
- 13-13
- 14-14
- 15-15
- 16-16
- 17-17
- 18-18
- 19-19
- 20-20
- 21-21
- 22-22
- 23-23
- 24-24
- 25-25
- 26-26
- 27-27
- 28-28
- 29-29
- 30-30
- 31-31
- 32-32
- 33-33
- 34-34
- 30
- 31
- 32
Disclaimer: I do not own BtVS or Legacies. I do not make any money from this story.
*
Cordelia Chase normally enjoyed gossiping, especially when it undermined her enemies. Well, frienemy was more accurate, as despite what some people might believe, she had never truly seen Willow and co as her enemies. Hell, back in their world, she barely gave Willow a second look, especially as back then, she was nothing but a background character. But now? Now the which was practically running Gehanna, so much so she was hosting the tattooing ceremony. It was appropriate, given the last one she had 'come out' as a top. And she did a reasonable job, considering it was very uneventful, at least compared with last time. Of course, she couldn't give her any credit. No, she and Harmony spent the entire night grumbling about how the event was very lacklustre. At least until the end.
"So, anymore tattoos?" Thirteen questioned.
"No, but I do have an announcement to make..." Willow spoke up, getting up on stage, and then speaking into the microphone, "Cordy, Harm, will you come up here."
"Why?" Cordelia frowned sceptically.
"Because I said so." Willow said coldly.
The two former popular girls looked at each other nervously, and then slowly made their way over to the stage where the witch was standing. Willow stared a hole through than the entire time, and then when they finally reached the top of the stairs, the witch recited some kind of incantation, and the next thing they knew, her former classmates were bound to the table in front of them. The one bitches lay on when they were getting a tattoo to solidify someone else's ownership over them. Which of course, had the two tops panicking, initially just trying to break free, before they came to their senses, and looked angry at their frienemy. They both clearly tried to control their anger momentarily, given how powerful Willow had become, but they couldn't help themselves.
"WILLOW? WHAT THE FUCK IS THIS?" Cordelia screeched.
"HOW DARE YOU! WHO DO YOU THINK YOU ARE?" Harmony yelled dumbly, although even she was smart enough to realize that she had fucked up by doing that.
"Who am I?" Willow raised an eyebrow, "I'm the one in charge around here. The top of tops. The, what was it Faith used to call herself? Oh yes, I'm the Alpha. And I can do whatever I want, no questions asked. Which is why I should have done this long ago, for everything you did to me back in school, but then you went and fucked my bitch without my permission. Do you remember that?"
"We do." Cordelia gulped, before really adding, "But we said we were sorry, and you said we were cool?"
"So sorry." Harmony whimpered pathetically.
"I know, and we were... as long as you didn't do anything else." Willow reminded them, "But the thing is, I hear you've been talking shit behind my back, in the hopes that someone would take me down. Or maybe trying to get support for trying to take over again? Or were you just kissing Amy's ass, because you think she's going to win?"
"No, no, no." Cordelia tried to protest.
"We would never." Harmony flat out lied.
"Silence!" Willow snapped, "This isn't a debate. It's a test. A test to see if you're worthy of being a top. All you have to do, is take one spanking from yours truly, without begging for mercy, and-"
"Mercy, mercy, MERCY!" Harmony cried out, and then when her best friend gave her a look she protested, "What? No way I can take a spanking from someone with magic powers. But maybe I can survive a butt fucking, and still be a top? I mean, you fuck my butt all the time, and I haven't broken yet, so..."
Taken aback by the sound strategy from Harmony of all people, Willow paused for a few long seconds, before grinning wickedly, "Wait... you couldn't break Harmony?"
"It's not like I was trying." Cordelia protested, before scolding her friend, "And it was supposed to be a secret."
"I know, but I need to prove I'm not a bottom." Harmony whined.
"All you've done is prove you're a bottom in denial." Willow scoffed, before smacking Cordelia's butt and began groping it, while asking her former bully, "Do you at least still have your butt cherry?"
"Yes." Cordelia whimpered softly, unsure if she should admit that or not.
"Good." Willow purred with delight, licking her lips before continuing, "See, I'm going to beat your asses for everything you've done. And if Cordy begs for mercy, well, looks like I'll add another anal cherry to my collection. If not? Maybe the girl who bullied me for years can avoid getting her virgin butt fucked. Maybe..."
Which suggested that maybe Cordelia would be better off following her best friend's lead, and begging for mercy right away, just so Willow would take it easy on her. However, her pride just wouldn't allow it. Besides, from the sounds of it, this was happening either way. And Willow clearly wasn't about to make it easy on them. No, with a few more magical words, Cordelia could feel her prison bottoms being pulled down, along with her underwear too, presenting her ass for the promised spanking. She was vaguely aware that Harmony was going through the same thing, the cameras making sure that their audience got the best possible look at it, who cheered happily, seemingly always welcoming the sight of a top getting knocked down a peg. Or in this case, two of them.
For a few long moments, Willow just admired the prize in front of her, first with her eyes, then with her hands, gleefully playing with that well-rounded flesh for a few moments, as her former bullies were left whimpering. Then they cried out pathetically, as instead of just starting the spanking off like that, the witch conjured up a couple of paddles, holding them up to her audience with wicked delight. Then, while that audience cheered, Willow made sure that Harmony and Cordelia got a good look at them. Oh God, all of a sudden Cordelia was regretting everything she'd ever done to the redheaded nerd. Hell, she was pretty much regretting all of her life choices. Especially after the first strike.
Harmony didn't want to be somebody's bitch, or worse, a slut. She had seen how those groups were treated, which was why she would do anything to firmly stay a top. Well, almost anything. Anything but this. Because she knew at least bitches and sluts seem to enjoy getting their asses fucked, and she too had liked it in the butt. Loved it, actually. It was certainly far more preferable to getting spanked. Especially with something which might as well have been a weapon, especially in the hands of a powerful witch, that she had pissed off. And yet, despite already submitting, Harmony was going to have to suffer the same fate as her best friend Cordelia, just because they had picked on the wrong nerd in high school. God, life was so unfair.
At least, she didn't have to suffer through the first strike. Then again, watching Cordelia's reaction to it wasn't exactly fun. No, it was very much the opposite of fun. As was watching Willow Rosenberg of all people raising that paddle high into the air, and bringing it crashing down on her best friend's butt. Then after a long pause she repeated the process over and over again, until the sound of each strike, and Cordelia's screams, echoed throughout all of Gehanna. Oh God, Harmony didn't want to watch another second of this, and yet, she couldn't look away. Like a car wreck, or a funny video about cats. Especially because she knew that inevitably she would suffer the same fate.
Sure enough, without any warning whatsoever, Willow switched over to giving Harmony's poor little butt a ridiculously hard strike. One that she was hopefully using her magic to increase her strength for, otherwise the former popular girls were going to be in for a very, very long night. It was far beyond what someone should ever give someone like Harmony. She wasn't a freak, dammit. Not in the sense of actually liking pain, and not in the sense of being a supernatural creature, like a Slayer, who could take this kind of abuse. And it wasn't like she had been that mean to Willow, had she? Sure, she had said a few mean things, but mostly it had been Cordy. She was the one who deserved this, dammit, so why were they both suffering?
Thankfully, the pain did eventually end, if very briefly, when Willow moved over to Cordelia again, and gave the former Queen of Sunnydale High her full attention. Which was something of a relief, even if her ass stung something fierce, and she became hyperaware of the fact that she had an audience cheering for her humiliation. And the fact it was hard to forget what was going to happen after this. Or the fact that at any second, the spanking could resume. And worst of all, it was only a matter of time before the spanking could get worse. Like when Willow started using both of those paddles, instead of just one. Oh God, there really was no way that Harmony could survive this without truly breaking.
Willow was very, very tempted to use both of those paddles right away, along with every ounce of strength she had in her body. Maybe even use every spell she knew to increase her strength, speed and stamina, so she could spank these hot little asses with everything she had. However, there was plenty of time for that later. Oh yes, she fully intended to give her bullies everything she had. But first, she would give them a nice, long, drawn-out spanking, given that she knew from her first experience with beating Faith's booty, among others, that it was so much more effective than simply going all out straightaway. Besides, she wanted this to last for as long as possible.
After all, this was Cordelia Chase and Harmony Kendall, the two girls above all others who had made her life hell in high school. Other than the actual monsters, of course. In a way, they were scarier. The monsters were inevitably killed off by her best friend, Buffy, but before the Slayer had come to town Willow was just a victim of the popular girls, and the words were more painful, and lasted longer, then any damage she had taken from following Buffy into danger. And while most of the popular girls had simply stood behind Cordelia and giggled, Harmony had gone out of her way to prove herself as the second meanest girl in school, and Cordy's bestie, by making the nerds suffer. Well now, it was payback time.
Payback which involved public humiliation, just like Willow and the other nerds had suffered through. Only, instead of simply insulting words, Cordelia and Harmony were actually getting their asses beat, so much so that they were screaming and crying as their butts, slowly turned bright pink, then light red, and then a dark and bruised red. Maybe best of all, those cheeks jiggled so wonderfully for her, Willow so hypnotized by them that she didn't even notice Cordelia begging for mercy. Hell, she was actually very impressed that the former popular girl had managed to hold back for so long, as normally bullies could dish it out, but they couldn't take it.
"MERCY, MERCY, MERCY!" Cordelia screeched at the top of her lungs towards the end, "I'M SORRY, I'M SORRY, I'M SORRY!"
Of course, when she realized she had got what she wanted, probably long ago, Willow grinned wickedly, and slowly started using both paddles to brutalize those bottoms with everything that she had. Now that was really what made those butts red and bruised. Also, it may have ventured into cruelty, as well. So cruel, Willow wasn't sure she would inflict this upon Faith if she was naughty. Of course, even at her worst, she wasn't sure she'd ever hated Faith more than these bitches at this moment. Although, as satisfying as this was in a very twisted way, it wouldn't be enough to break them. Not really. No, for that she would need something more mutually pleasurable. So the witch abruptly stopped, throw away the paddles, leaned over and yanked the heads of Cordelia and Harmony up by their hair.
"Have you bitches got something you want to say to me?" Willow snapped angrily.
"I'm sorry, Mistress Willow." Cordelia whimpered pathetically.
"Me too. I'm sorry, ah fuck, I'm so sorry, Mistress Willow..." Harmony parroted weakly, before adding, "I'm sorry, I'll do anything to make it up to you."
"Harm!" Cordelia whined.
"Damn right, you will." Willow said firmly, using magic to remove the restraints, before walking around to the centre of the stage and announcing, "You'll do anything I say, because I'm the Alpha female around here, mmmmmmmmmmmm, and you're nowhere near sorry enough. But I know how you might be. Ooooooooooh yessssssss, you can earn my forgiveness, by kissing my ass. Oh yes, mmmmmmmmm, pucker up! I want my former high school bullies to literally kiss my ass, ohhhhhhhhhhhh, and share the honour of tonguing my butt hole. Yeahhhhhhhhhhh, kiss the hole I shit from, you bitches. Then maybe I'll forgive you for everything you've done."
"Yes, Mistress Willow." Cordelia whimpered softly after a brief pause.
"Yes, Mistress Willow..." Harmony then parroted weakly.
Cordelia couldn't believe it had come to this. Literally kissing Willow Rosenberg's ass. She and her best friend Harmony actually kneeling down behind like the biggest nerd ever, and both pressing their lips to her cheeks at the same time. Worse still, they were doing this after getting spanked, their asses still feeling like they were on fire after the brutal beating they had taken, to the point that moving at all was a chore. One small relief was they were no longer tied down, but even then, it wasn't much comfort, given that they had to become ass kissers, and publicly, no less. Thankfully not in front of many of their former classmates, but considering what the tops of Gehanna might do to them at the end of this, the result was worse.
Something that Cordelia and Harmony tried to put out of their minds, as they pressed one lingering kiss to a butt cheek each, followed by another, and another, and another. Because they were working together like that, it took no time at all to cover those cheeks in kisses. But of course, it wasn't enough for Mistress Willow. Admittedly, if the roles were reversed, it wouldn't be nearly enough for Cordelia. No, she would take full advantage of this situation, and really make her defeated enemy wallow in humiliation. And after all of this, that's exactly what Willow was to her now. An enemy she was determined to get revenge on. Especially considering what was to come, and the nerd's surprising enthusiasm when it came to dishing out commentary.
"Yesssssssssssss, that's it! That's exactly it, oooooooooooh fuck! Kiss my ass, Cordy! Oh my God, you have no idea how long I've wanted to say that to you, ha ha ha ha!" Willow laughed, drunk with power and lust, "Both of you. Oh yeah, you always thought you were better than me. Throwing your weight around, and acting so superior. The only difference is, back in high school you were tragic stereotypes. But in Gehanna? You were just begging someone to put you in your place. Well, you're in luck, because now you're finally getting what you really want. The chance to kiss a superior woman's ass, mmmmmmmmm, and so much more. Speaking of which, get your face in between my cheeks, and show my butt hole some love. Ohhhhhhhhhhh yeahhhhhhhhh, it's time for you to really start earning your forgiveness from me. Ohhhhhhhhhh yesssssssssss, that's it Harmony, mmmmmmmmm, just like that, ooooooooooooh fuckkkkkkkkkkkkk, ha ha, good little butt licker."
It was truly horrifying to Cordelia that Harmony was so willing to obey, as it was evidence of how far her friend had already fallen. But mostly, she resented the fact that she had been beaten to the punch, that maybe, just maybe, rimming the witch first would earn just enough brownie points to opt out of the butt fucking. Or at least for Mistress Willow to be gentle with her, which definitely wasn't a guarantee right now. If anything, it was at exactly the opposite, given their long history together. And whatever the case, she had no choice now. Hell, if she tried to resist, the witch would just use her magic. There was a decent excuse, at least. So as soon as Harmony finally pulled back, and gave her a chance to please, for better or for worse, Cordelia didn't hesitate.
No, she pressed her face deep in between those cheeks, and started lapping away at Willow Rosenberg's ass hole. Which shouldn't be a big deal, given was far from the first time that she had given a rim job. Hell, this was far preferable to the literal ass kissing. At least this was something that other tops did. Sometimes even with each other. Like Cordelia and Harmony. Especially Cordelia rimming Harmony, as she'd wanted to take care of her best friend, and really prepare her for an ass fucking. Besides, it was more fun when it was with her bestie. Of course, this was very different, and the former popular girl was left with overwhelming feelings of humiliation, as she continued to tongue that back hole.
Willow had made her point, and there was a very good argument that she should show mercy, and let her former bullies off the hook. That would be a very unpopular decision with the crowd, but there was a time where Cordelia Chase really, truly felt like a friend. Not a really close friend, but a friend. But, even if Willow ignored everything that happened in high school, Cordy had done more than enough to earn a butt wrecking, and being demoted to a mindless anal slut, just with her actions within Gehanna. As for Harmony, well... the witch wasn't going to lose any sleep over that. And of course, focusing on the high school stuff just made all of this so much more satisfying. And yet, it wasn't enough.
She wanted more. So much more. And there was an easy way she could get it, mostly by moving on to the main event. However, now she was here, doing this, and she wanted to savour it for as long. Savour the feeling of Cordelia Chase and Harmony Kendall taking it in turns to eat her ass, and then eventually together, and she ordered it. And grabbed the back of their heads, and pushed their faces together. Which was good for all of them, because that unofficial couple got to kiss while tonguing her butt hole. Although she didn't keep her hands on them for long. No, she was far too busy cupping her tits with one hand, and then frantically rubbing her aching cunt with the other.
This was another very questionable move, as while with a little help from Cordelia and Harmony, she could make herself cum this way, Willow wasn't sure she should give them the satisfaction. And more importantly, she should be saving her strength for the ass wrecking. Because sure, she could use her magic to increase her strength, speed and stamina, but she wanted to use every ounce of it on those asses. First with her hands, during the spanking, and then with the cock, during the butt fucking. That way she could really brutalize the asses of Cordelia Chase and Harmony Kendall inside and out. However, ultimately she just couldn't resist giving herself some satisfaction, and pushing herself closer to orgasm with every movement of her hands, the tongues of her former bullies, and every word out of her mouth.
"Yeahhhhhhhhhhhhh, get that tongue deep. Deep in my fucking ass! Oooooooooooooh yessssssssssssss, eat it! Ah fuck!" Willow cried out with increasing volume, "Yesssssssssssss, get your pretty little faces as deep as they can go into my fucking shit hole! Mmmmmmmmmm, that feels so good. Soooooooooooo goooooooooooddddddddddd, I love it when bottoms eat my ass! Mmmmmmmmm, and Cordelia Chase and Harmony Kendall are world-class butt munchers! Yes they are, yes they are, ohhhhhhhhhhh fuck, munch my butt, you bitches! Help me cum like the bottoms you are! Ooooooooooooooh yessssssssssss, like the sluts you are! Oh yes! Ohhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh yesssssssssssss! OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH YEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEESSSSSSSSSSSSSSS, FUCK ME, AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH FUCKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK!"
Eventually Willow did cum, and while it wasn't even close to one of the best orgasms she'd had within Gehanna, it just may be better than what she had got outside of it. Especially given that Cordelia and Harmony didn't pause eating her ass for a second. No, now they were really into it, frantically tonguing her butt hole, like it was precious to them. Like she really was their Mistress now. Something which was very, very tempting. But no, she had more than enough on her hands with Faith, and in a way, Dawn. And speaking of those two hot bottoms, Willow had the perfect way that the two of them could help out with putting Harmony Kendall and especially Cordelia Chase in their places.
"Faith, Dawn, mmmmmmmmm, get over here, and lay down on the stage." Willow ordered, as she gently bought herself down from her high, and then sucked her own fingers clean.
"Yes, Mistress Willow." Faith eagerly replied and obeyed.
"Yes, Mistress Willow." Dawn eagerly replied and obeyed.
"Good girls." Willow chuckled wickedly, before casting a spell, which equipped herself, Dawn and Faith with strap-ons. She then turned her attention back to her former bullies, and ordered them, "Now, you can further prove yourselves as shameless bottoms, by writing those cocks with your cunts. Ooooooooooooooh yesssssssssssss, I love watching bottoms riding each other. It's so, cute."
"Yes, Mistress Willow." Harmony replied and obeyed.
"Yes, Mistress Willow." Cordelia replied and obeyed.
Harmony and Cordelia were noticeably less eager, especially Cordy, given they knew where this was going. The big difference was that Harmony had more or less accepted her fate, and after everything they had just gone through, she was very much of the opinion that they deserved a reward. And the rare treat of having a cock in her cunt sounded wonderful, especially right now. In fact, while the brunette was no doubt afraid of what might happen after that, the blonde was looking forward to it, Oh yes, she knew where this was going, if they were good, and she would welcome it, if it meant cumming, like she did when Cordelia fucked her. So unlike her best friend, 'Harm' was only too happy to straddle a cock, and push herself downwards when lining herself up properly.
This got her another dirty look from her best friend, although she didn't know why. If Mistress Willow wanted them to suck those strap-ons first, she would have definitely said something. And it wasn't like they needed it, given how wet they were. That didn't stop Cordy from rebelling somewhat, reaching for that cock with her mouth, and following through pushing it past her lips and then her throat. Admittedly, it happened much faster than it probably would have otherwise, Cordelia taking the upper half into her throat, and then spitting on the lower half, before rubbing it into the shaft with her hand. Only then did she join Harmony in positioning her needy little pussy over the dildo, and slowly but surely pushing herself all the way down.
Of course, to no one's surprise, Harmony didn't exactly wait for Cordelia. No, by the time her best friend was ready to follow in her footsteps, Harmony was pretty much sitting on Dawn's lap, something that she got to savour for a few long seconds, while inch after inch of girl cock slid into Cordy's cunt. Harmony also enjoying the irony of that. She and Cordy had tried and failed to push Dawnie into topping, then very much enjoyed using her when she was broken by Buffy. Now in a way, things had come full circle. Except, of course, the fact that Dawn was basically nothing but a toy Mistress Willow was using to put on a show. Which she continued to do, by shoving her cock in their faces. Once they were in position.
"Good bitches." Willow chuckled, as she began to slap her cock against the faces of her former bullies, "Now, HERE is your chance to suck cock. Mmmmmmmmm yeahhhhhhhhhh, and show off the only thing you really learned in high school. Oooooooooooh yesssssssssssss, everyone knows that while Willow Rosenberg was busy studying, Cordelia Chase and Harmony Kendall were just sucking cock, and spreading their legs. Otherwise known as practicing what you're good at. Ohhhhhhhhhhhh yeahhhhhhhhh, and clearly, it was time well spend for you two, mmmmmmmmmm, because apparently you're great cock suckers. You might want to start fingering those butts, though. Because apparently, you should have been practicing more for the day that you become my ass whore, and the anal sluts of everyone in this prison."
Which of course, resulted in laughter from the crowd, and Harmony quickly reaching around, and stuffing a finger pretty much straight up her ass dry. Which hurt, but it beat the alternative. And honestly, she liked the feeling of having a cock in her mouth, as well as her cunt, and she wanted to get a preview of being triple stuffed. Something that she was sure would happen very soon. Apparently Cordelia felt the same way, as with a soft whimper, she also fingered her butt. She made sure to suck on her fingers first, and do it very slowly, but she did it. Oh yes, Cordelia Chase publicly fingered her own butt, something that Mistress Willow decided to get a better look at.
"Okay, that's enough of that. Mmmmmmmmmm, now let's see what progress you've made on those holes." Willow said, pulling her cock away from those mouths, and moving around where she could get the best look at the former popular girls fingering their butts. Something she just had to stare at for a few long seconds, before finally continuing the taunting, "Wow... fuck me, that's hot. Ooooooooooooh yeahhhhhhhhhhhhhh, it's sooooooooooo hot seeing Cordelia Chase and Harmony Kendall fingering their slutty little ass holes, and getting them nice and ready for real women to fuck. Real women like me. Oh yes, how does it feel girls? Huh? How does it feel to use those holes for their intended purpose? Or at least, to get ready for it?"
"Good, Mistress Willow. Mmmmmmmmmmm, sooooooooooooo goooooooooooooddddddddddd." Harmony moaned happily, completely lost in the moment, "I love it! I love fingering my own ass. Mmmmmmmmm, oooooooooooohhhhhhhhhhhh yeahhhhhhhhhhh, I love it up the butt. Oh please, fuck me! Fuck my slutty little shit hole! Pound it hard, and make me a slut."
"Yeah, good Mistress Willow." Cordelia just whimpered in reply.
"Yeah, that's what I thought." Willow grinned, before announcing, "And I think the two of you are ready for fucking, don't you?"
"Yes Mistress Willow." Harmony moaned her approval, once again without hesitation.
"Yes, Mistress Willow." Cordelia whimpered, knowing that no other response was acceptable.
"I wasn't asking, " Willow admitted with a wicked grin, before making another announcement, "But I shouldn't be greedy, when there is another piece of ass here to use, see who wants to join me? Huh? Mmmmmmmmm, who wants the first piece of Harmony Kendall, at least for tonight, and the chance to butt fuck these bottoms side by side with me?"
There was then a chorus of, "Me, Mistress Willow, me!"
"Relax, you'll get your turn..." Willow reminded them, before making a choice, "Lizzie Saltzman, would you please join me?"
"Of course, Mistress Willow. Thank you, Mistress Willow." Lizzie quickly replied and obeyed, ignoring the grumblings.
"I know, I know, I spoil her. But what can I say, us witches have to stick together.” Willow pointed out, "Besides, she can pass for my best friend, mmmmmmmmm, and me and Buffy definitely should have done this on our first day in Gehanna. Or Buffy's first day in Sunnydale. Oooooooooooh yes, but I'm sure will make up for lost time when she comes back. For now? Spread your cheeks, bitches. Give us those holes!"
"Yes, Mistress Willow." Harmony replied and obeyed.
"Yes, Mistress Willow." Cordelia replied and obeyed.
Cordelia couldn't believe this was actually happening. After all this time in Gehanna, while somehow hanging onto her anal cherry, keeping away from truly terrifying women, she was giving it up to Willow Rosenberg of all people. And publicly, no less. Then again, Willow had become ridiculously powerful, a far cry from what she was in high school, and Cordelia feared what would happen if she tried to deny her. Especially after all that she had done. Maybe especially back in high school. Because as she was forced to look down at Faith's smirking face, it was increasingly hard to believe that anyone would care about this slut. Although either way, the result was the same, poor Cordy having to reach back and spread her cheeks, offering up her virgin butt hole to a girl she used to bully.
At the very least, this should be something that Dawnie and Faith were doing, but obviously Willow wanted to provide her even a little bit more humiliation. To make matters worse, she ended up face to face with her best friend in the process, both of them having to lean forward and turn their faces to the sides, where they could see each other. And while both witches admire the sight in front of them, the anal penetration wasn't simultaneous. No, after only a few long seconds, Lizzie closed the distance between them, pressed the head of her strap-on against Harmony's butt hole, and pushed forwards. Oh God, Cordelia had to watch her best friend getting anally taken, while knowing that it was about to happen to her.
The fact that Lizzie was using her favourite fuck hole certainly didn't help, but Cordelia quickly forgot about that when she felt something knocking on her back door, which was of course, Willow Rosenberg's cock. Oh God, that nerdy little loser Willow Rosenberg was now pressing the head of her cock against Cordelia Chase's shit hole, and then after another few long minutes of savouring the moment, she pushed forwards, causing that forbidden hole to start stretching forward. Ah fuck, Willow Rosenberg was stretching her fucking ass! And it just kept stretching, and stretching, and stretching, until the strap-on slid through it and into Cordelia's butt. Which made it official, Willow Rosenberg had just taken Cordelia Chase's anal cherry.
Something that of course Willow just had to comment on, "I did it! I got your cherry! Mmmmmmmmm yessssssssssssss, Willow Rosenberg has just taken Cordelia Chase's anal cherry! Wow, you should have really been nicer to me in high school, huh? Or just after? Maybe then there wouldn't be a dick in your ass, huh? But that's okay, mmmmmmmmm yeahhhhhhhhhhh, because I'm going to take real good care of your butt hole. Oooooooooooooh yeahhhhhhhhhhhhhh, I'm going to stretch it out real good, and get you ready for a nice hard rectum wrecking. Ohhhhhhhhhhhhh yesssssssssssss, just you wait, Cordy. I'm going to loosen up this ass real good., and all you have to do, is take it like a good girl. Oh yes, take it Cordy! Take every inch in your tight little virgin ass hole! Oooooooooooohhhhhhhhhhhhh fuck yeah!"
Poor Cordy could offer up no reply. She used to be the master of the come back, but what could she possibly say, when there was a cock in her ass? Nothing, that's what. All she could do was cry out in agony as her butt cherry was roughly taken from her, and then whimper pathetically as well, as Willow let Cordelia wallow in her humiliation. Then when she did finally continue the anal violation, it was agonizingly slow, which was the worst possible outcome for Cordy. If Willow took her hard and rough it would be agonizing, but at least she wouldn't like it. But it seemed her former victim wouldn't be satisfied with anything less than turning the former popular girl into a broken little slut. And she would almost certainly succeed, because this was unbearably humiliating, and yet somehow, part of Cordelia was liking this.
Willow was of course loving this, and was baffled by her decision not to do it sooner. Sure, she had the perfect piece of ass known as Faith Lehane to break-in, and that had been a full-time job. However, it quickly became clear that Faith was just a cocky bottom in denial, waiting for someone to put her in her place. She had also suspected that Cordelia was untrustworthy, but she had been so distracted with her cellmate, the blossoming relationship between Buffy and Dawn, and trying to escape this place that she almost missed out on the perfect excuse to get revenge on a school bully. Oh well, Willow fully intended to make up for lost time right now, by making the once mighty Cordelia Chase her anal bitch.
Like Faith? It was very tempting. Maybe especially with Harmony in the mix, that way, nerdy little Willow Rosenberg could have three girls who looked down her nose at her in high school as her personal property. But then, Faith was insatiable, always needing a cock up her ass, and Willow always wanted to pound that perfect little fuck hole. Besides, she loved the idea of turning her old bullies into free to use fuck sluts, who's shit holes were relentlessly pounded by her and the rest of the tops. In fact, it was now the redheaded geek who was the most popular girl around, and she had the power to order the other tops to use Harmony and Cordelia as frequently as they could. And either way, it would be wonderful revenge.
Of course, while she couldn't help but think that was a wonderful future she was in for, now these bitches were under her control, Willow couldn't forget about the current heaven she was living in. Namely, watching inch after inch of her strap-on cock sliding into Cordelia Chase's tailpipe, via the wide-open crater which was currently her ass hole. And even better, Harmony Kendall was receiving the exact same treatment right beside them, albeit from another cock. Although it was strapped around the waist of a beautiful blonde, who could pass for Buffy, and in reality was another powerful witch. So either way, it was an absolute triumph as far as she was concerned.
Sadly, the butt stuffing wasn't quite simultaneous. No, Lizzie eventually slowed down so she could catch up a little bit, but there was only so long before she had the rest of the dildo into the other blonde's butt. To be fair, Willow would've probably done the same thing if the roles were reversed, and it was impossible for her to be mad in this moment. Not when those thighs came to rest against first the well-rounded butt cheeks of Harmony Kendall, and then an even plumper ass cheeks of Cordelia Chase, announcing that the two mean girls were anally stuffed. And double stuffed for that matter, given there was still a cock each of their cunts. Still, Willow was in charge here, and she would remind Lizzie she needed to be more patient. For now she distracted from that minor disobedience, by taunting her former bullies again.
"Every inch! Oooooooooooh yeahhhhhhhhhhhh, that's every single inch of my cock in Cordelia Chase's shit-pipe, and every single inch of another cock in Harmony Kendall's shitter!" Willow gleefully taunted and in the nastiest language she could think of, and then quickly added, "While their cunts are full of cock, making them two double stuffed lesbian whores! Ohhhhhhhhhhhhh fuck yeah, mmmmmmmmmm yessssssssssssss, Cordelia Chase and Harmony Kendall are whores! DP whores! My little dyke sluts, who I'm going to whore out to everyone here! Oh yeah, we're all gonna fuck you, just like this. Ooooooooooohhhhhhhhhhhh yeeeeeeeeeeeeeessssssssssssss, take it, you bitches! Take it like the sluts you always were, mmmmmmmmmm, including in high school."
Lizzie was feeling very worried right now, given that Mistress Willow could read minds, and knew full well, that both blondes in this equation were guilty of being mean girls in high school. Hell, Lizzie was arguably even more guilty, given how her mean girl behaviour was far more recent. Ever since befriending Hope Mikaelson, she'd made great progress, but she was definitely guilty of backsliding more than she would like to admit. Luckily for her, Mistress Willow seemed focused on punishing the mean girls who had wronged her. Or maybe more accurately, the main mean girl. Oh yes, she was very much focused on Cordelia, pretty much leaving Harmony's fate up to Lizzie. Which was a good thing, because Lizzie wasn't sure she could find a way to punish this girl through anal, given how much she obviously loved it.
Admittedly she didn't love it quite as much as Faith, Dawn, and a few of the other anal sluts Lizzie had been using pretty much on a daily basis ever since she got here. Those butt whores got pure pleasure just from getting their shit holes violated, whereas Harmony's initial cry was of pure pain. However, there was definitely a hint of pleasure of throughout the butt stuffing, and it became much more obvious when Lizzie started thrusting her hips back and forth, officially starting the sodomy. Oh yes, given the cries that she was letting out, it was very clear that this wasn't Harmony's first time taking it up the butt, as in what seemed like no time at all her rectum relaxed, and allowed her to enjoy being sodomized.
It was much the same story with Cordelia, except it may have taken her a little bit longer to actually enjoy herself. Although it wasn't by much, as Mistress Willow was easily the best butt buster in all of Gehanna. Which was very impressive, given that she hadn't been doing this for that long in the grand scheme of things, from what Lizzie had heard. Although clearly, she had made up for that by dishing out so many ass fuckings. Ever since she got here, that she had become the best. God knows, it felt like an honour to watch her work, Lizzie's eyes constantly wondering to her at a time like this, as she found herself imagining what it would be like to be on the receiving end of that treatment. Not as much as she wanted to be that good at butt fucking, but still.
To be fair, it was more of a problem when she was just watching with her sister Josie. Now she had a better distraction, given that it was her cock sliding in and out of a bottom's bitch hole. Admittedly she didn't really care about this bottom, but her ass hole did look really good stretching for that cock, and it was taking every inch of it, like a good little fuck hole. Also, right beside her there was a big bottomed brunette, who was getting that fat ass of hers fucked, and that was really, inspiring. It definitely helped Lizzie refocus her energy into topping, unfortunately just in time for her to be ordered to stop. But that was okay, because the night wasn't over yet. Far from it, in fact.
"Lizzie, let's pull out and give someone else a turn." Willow ordered, then turned to the crowd, who were all looking at her eagerly, and then quickly added, "Namely your sister, and your bestie. Mmmmmmmmmm yeahhhhhhhhhhhhh, come up here, Hope and Josie. Show off what good friends you are, by butt fucking these bitches together."
"Yes, Mistress Willow." Josie eagerly replied and obeyed.
"Yes, Mistress Willow." Hope then replied and obeyed.
"Yes, Mistress Willow." Lizzie reluctantly replied and obeyed.
Josie wasn't surprised that her sister was the last to reply, and the most reluctant to obey, given it seemed like she had just got a good rhythm going, before being asked to stop. Not that she could blame her for getting distracted, given how familiar that big fat ass that Cordelia had was. Hell, more than a few times, it had her looking down, and to the side, at Hope's big booty. Thankfully her friend was either too distracted to notice, or simply didn't want to make anything of it. Either way Josie was grateful, as it didn't seem like the right time to make a move on the mighty Hope Mikaelson. Not when she could so publicly lose. Even if it wouldn't be that bad, given the sounds that Cordelia and Harmony were making.
Thankfully they continue to make them as first Mistress Willow, and then Lizzie pulled their cocks out of their asses, and they were replaced by first Josie, and then Hope. With the chance to sodomize a big booty brunette on the line, Josie had been quick to position herself nearest to that prize, hoping that Hope would allow her to have it. She wasn't sure whether that was a conscious decision, or whether her friend was just too occupied by watching the show to get there first, but either way, the result was the same. Namely Josie Saltzman getting behind Cordelia Chase, lining up her strap-on to that already slightly gaping butt hole, and pushing inside it. Something which had the bitch crying out in mostly pleasure, and in turn Josie smirking in triumph.
She then briefly waited for her best friend to catch up. It wasn't a long wait, and soon the two girls were slowly making their way deep into the bowels of Cordelia Chase and Harmony Kendall. Which was something they savoured every moment of, given that the two bitchy girls continue to spread their cheeks nice and wide, providing the perfect view of inch after inch of those dildos disappearing into their butts. Something everyone around them was equally fascinated by, including Mistress Willow and Lizzie. Oh yes, there was something more fun they were no doubt about to do, but they took the time to watch the second ass stuffing for these two sluts. The second of many. Probably both tonight, and from here on out.
Once their thighs were resting against butt cheeks, which the two tops took a few long seconds to savour, before officially starting the sodomy. Initially they were just as fascinated by those butt holes stretching around those strap-ons, which were now pumping in and out, instead of just disappearing into them. However, it wasn't long before Mistress Willow and Lizzie made their move, providing quite the show in the process. One which seemed to fascinate Hope, and it certainly fascinated Josie. At least initially. But for this to happen, Cordelia and Harmony had to let go of their cheeks, and this meant Josie's thighs were smacking against a big pair of meaty ass cheeks, making it very easy for her to imagine that she was butt fucking someone else with a beautifully big booty.
"Okay bitches, you've done a decent job so far, but now I think it's time to kick it up a notch." Willow announced, deliberately being vague about who she was talking to, until she also clarified, "And by that, I of course mean you two sluts. Because sure, you've proven beyond a shadow of a doubt at being good at taking two cocks at once, but how are you to taking three? Huh? Let's find out, shall we? Oooooooooooh yesssssssssssss, take these cocks into your whore mouths, and become triple stuffed sluts! Ohhhhhhhhhhhhhh yeahhhhhhhhhhhh, mmmmmmmmmm, I wanna see Cordelia Chase and Harmony Kendall taking a cock in each of their fuck holes. Oooooooooooooooohhhhhhhhhhhhhh yeeeeeeeeeeeeeessssssssssssss, mmmmmmmmmm, that's it! Take it! Take it like the sluts you are!"
"Take those ass flavoured cocks." Lizzie chimed in, not wanting to be left out, and wanting to impress Mistress Willow, "Ooooooooooh yessssssssss, take those cocks, which have just been in the deepest part of your fucking shit-pipes, and deep into your mouths as you can. And by that, I mean your throats. Oh yes, deep throat those cocks. Mmmmmmmmm fuck yeah, you love that shit, don't you? Huh? Yeah you do. Ohhhhhhhhhhhhhh yeahhhhhhhhhhhhh, I know your type. You think you're so tough, but in the end, you just want to be someone's bitch! Oh yeah, take it deep! Take it all, and get every drop of your best friend's butt cream, like the nasty little ass to mouth whore you are!"
Harmony had tasted her own ass many times on Cordelia's strap-on dick, and loved it. Maybe a little too much, given that she was supposed to be a top, or at least, a secret switch, but she couldn't help it. It was just so yummy, and a silver lining to all of this was. she would be definitely tasting it and again during all of this. Probably more times than ever before. But she was also hoping that she would be able to taste another ass in the process. And she had. Mistress Willow's. Which don't get her wrong, had been really yummy, but that hadn't been exactly what she had in mind. Thankfully, Mistress Willow was only too happy to provide her with what she really wanted, and sooner than she suspected.
She thought for sure that Mistress Willow would want to see Cordelia taste her own butt the very first chance she got, but no, she was nice enough to give Harmony the first taste. Admittedly she probably didn't see that as a good thing. No, the intention was probably to further humiliate her former bullies, by making them taste their best friend's booty. Especially given the redhead seemed surprised by how eager the blonde was to obey. Surprised, but delighted. Admittedly, Cordelia was probably less enthusiastic, which helped, but Harmony's enthusiasm definitely seemed to be a factor in why Mistress Willow was grinning so widely, and she continue to provide verbal encouragement, along with Mistress Lizzie.
Not that Harmony really paid attention to it. No, she was busy savouring the yummy flavour of her best friend's butt, and of course, trying to get every drop of it. Which wasn't easy for her, as it would be for a full time bottom, but at least she wasn't poor Cordy, who was out of practice with this kind of thing. Hell, Cordelia had confessed to her that she wasn't a big fan of giving a BJ anyway, mostly just dishing out hand jobs in high school, and not exactly racing to do more directly afterwards. It was only really in Gehanna that she had gone all the way, even allowing Harmony to do it. Well, they had left her anal cherry intact, which it turns out, might have actually been a mistake.
There was just no way that her best friend could survive the humiliation of being butt fucked by Willow Rosenberg of all people, and then pretty much everyone in Gehanna. Or at least, all the tops. Although maybe that would be good thing, given how amazing this experience was. Hell, by the time she was deep throating the full length of that dildo, Harmony wondered why she had ever bothered being a top, when she knew just how much fun bottoming was. Or more accurately, she thought she knew, but the truth was, it was so much better. Especially when she was in the centre of a gang bang just like this. And especially when her best friend, and kind of secret girlfriend, was receiving the exact same treatment. And from a lot of hot women, at that. Including Willow Rosenberg. Oh yes, they were dyking out with that nerd, and Harmony was loving every moment of it.
Cordelia was loving every minute of it too, if she was honest with herself. Especially when Hope and Josie replaced Lizzie and Mistress Willow, and two more tops started sodomizing the former popular girls. Honestly at that point, Cordelia had no idea who, and she didn't care. It didn't really matter, because it felt like every single top left in Gehanna had a piece of her ass. And fed it to her. Or Harmony's booty. Which was wonderful, and terrible, all at the same time. And not even because it meant that she was done as a top. No, that had been true from the beginning, when she and her best friend were publicly spanked, seemingly in front of everyone. It would be hard for them to come back from that, but a public gang bang? That was impossible.
Strangely, knowing that she was done as a top was oddly cathartic. Cordelia had worked so hard to reach the top, and stay there, pretty much as long as she could remember, and it had been so exhausting. Now it felt like she could truly relax, and just accept whatever fate Mistress Willow had in store for her. Which she deserved, for ever thinking that she could push such a goddess around. God, how could she have been so stupid? Willow Rosenberg was obviously superior to her in every way, and she always had been. Cordelia should count herself lucky that something like this hadn't happen sooner. Hell, part of her even wished that it had, because again, this was weirdly relaxing. And it felt so very, very good.
That was also kind of the problem, given that it felt so good. Cordelia never wanted it to end. But it had too. One way or another. The only question now was, WHEN she was going to beg to cum. Because she really, really wanted to do it much sooner than she did, but for better or for worse, her time as a top paid off, and she was able to hold back for what felt like hours of agonizing pleasure. Of course, she had been far from the greatest top, not like Mistress Willow, and even Mistress Willow had her limits. So she waited until the beautiful redhead was about to have another turn with her ass, and then Cordelia pleaded at the top of her lungs for what she so desperately needed.
"Please make me cum! I need to cum! Please? I fucking need it!" Cordelia pleaded desperately, "Oh please, Mistress Willow, ruin my ass! Mmmmmmmmmm yeahhhhhhhhhhh, wreck my fucking shit hole! Take me, ooooooooooooooooh, take your revenge for everything I did to you in high school! I was a bitch to you then, and now I'm your bitch! Your anal loving bitch! Ohhhhhhhhhhhhhhh yessssssssssssss, pound me! Pound my ass hole! Oh yes, OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH YEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS, FUCK ME FUCK ME FUCKKKKKKKKKKKKKK MEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE!"
Luckily for her, it wasn't long before she got exactly what she so desperately needed. Namely, Mistress Willow ramming her cock as deep inside of her as it would go, and then pounding her slutty little ass to orgasm. Not that it took that much. No, all it really took in the end was receiving a slightly harder fucking, and then she went crashing over the edge. Although to be fair, every time the cock in her ass pushed forwards, it pushed her downwards onto the cock in her cunt. And the one in her mouth, for that matter. Oh yes, Cordelia and Harmony were brutally pounded in all three of their holes, making them cum over and over again, and forgot all about being tops.
Willow wasn't sure she'd ever struggled this much not to cum right away. She really, truly loved each and every time with Faith, but she was unsure if anything had been this special with her. Except of course, for the wonderful day that she had come out as a top, and let everyone in Gehanna know that Faith was her bitch. And of course, their first time together. But even then, this was like both of those occasions rolled into one. God, in that moment, Willow had never been more tempted to keep Cordelia for herself. But again, the idea of having her school bully as a free to use slut was just too perfect. Not that she could think too much about the future of course. No, she had to concentrate on pounding that ass, and preventing herself from cumming.
If it wasn't for her magic, she would've probably cum long before this, especially with the beautiful sight in front of her. Fuck, when did Cordelia Chase get such a big booty? Harmony's was well-rounded too, and seeing them jiggle was heavenly. Especially as in one case, she could feel it. And they went back to shamelessly sucking cock, right after they got what they wanted. Admittedly, that was only partly up to them, but it was still incredibly hot. And the other end of the harness bashing against her clit, and the sheer joy of what she was doing, meant that she was only postponing the inevitable. So ultimately, she just had to make sure she came in style.
Namely by yanking back on Cordelia's hair, smacking that fat booty, and yelling at the top of her lungs, "TAKE IT, YOU WHORE! TAKE IT RIGHT UP YOUR BITCH ASS! YEAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH, TAKE IT LIKE YOU THE BITCH YOU ARE! THE BITCH I MADE YOU! MMMMMMMMMMMMMM YESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS, YOU WERE SUCH A BITCH IN HIGH SCHOOL, BUT NOW YOU'RE MY BITCH! YESSSSSSSSSSSSS, OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOH FUCKKKKKKKKKKKKKK, YOU'RE MY ANAL LOVING BITCH, AND YOUR SHIT HOLE IS A FUCK HOLE, BECAUSE OF ME! OHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH YEAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH, AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHH GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOODDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!"
Those words combined with everything else had her cumming wonderfully hard. However, even though it was one of the most satisfying climaxes of her life, she didn't need magic to push herself through it. Both so that she could have the same experience. Again, and so she could make sure she thoroughly humiliated her former bullies. God, it was so tempting just to use every ounce of her strength, and collapse with exhaustion, just so that she could have another precious second of humiliating the former popular girls. And just being inside Cordelia Chase's big booty, for that matter. But the one thing more important than that, was maintaining her control over Gehanna.
So in the end she staggered back with barely any energy left. However, everyone was far too preoccupied with the new fuck holes to notice. Which briefly made her wonder whether she made a mistake not giving the last of the energy she had to this ass pounding. But no, she definitely made the right decision, because it meant that she could sit back, and watch Cordelia Chase and Harmony Kendall getting completely destroyed, and if what was easily one of the greatest moments of her life. And she got to share it with Faith and Dawn, who were also allowed to cum thanks to the other end of their dildos bashing against their clits. So much so, that they eventually crawled out from underneath Cordelia and Harmony so they could snuggle up with Willow, and just enjoy the show.
Hope always had a lot of fun anally pounding a bitch, and this was definitely no exception. Just like Mistress Willow, she held off herself as long as she could, then ultimately came hard and frequently. Which was wonderful. It really was. However, there was a weird sense of disconnection. It felt like she had done it all before, and it just wasn't as exciting as the first time. And she hated the idea that she had done it all in only a few weeks. Which once again bought her back to thinking about the Saltzman twins, and how much more satisfying this would be if she was butt fucking one of them. Or... maybe, vice versa? Which was the wrong thing to think of, especially now, but she just couldn't help herself.
As the tribrid, she had Mistress Willow levels of stamina, meaning that she was able to watch both Lizzie and Josie go to town on Cordelia Chase's fat ass, without ever really losing focus on sodomizing Harmony. And it was easy for her to imagine herself in the place of Cordelia, and to her shame, it made her cum that much harder thinking about it. And she wanted it even more. For the Saltzman sisters to spit roast Cordelia again, like they had before. However, this time, neither one went in for cleaning. Which was fine, because there was a shortage of cocks to ram down the throats of the newly broken in bottoms, but it was still rather odd. And it only became stranger, once Hope was finally done.
"Come with us." Lizzie came up to Hope and whispered firmly into her ear, "Right now."
"Okay." Hope said without hesitation.
"And don't bother having those sluts clean your cock." Lizzie quickly added, before grinning, "We have someone special in mind to do that."
"Whatever." Hope said dismissively.
If she wasn't so preoccupied in watching the perverted display in front of her, Hope may have thought more about those words, and questioned her friends in public. But she just couldn't help staring at Cordelia and Harmony getting triple stuffed, right up until the moment that they were out of sight. God, she wasn't sure she'd ever moved so slowly. Not that she really sped up, when they were out of sight. First, because she was busy enjoying the sounds and smells of the sex, but the further they got away from them, the more she thought about those words that one of her best friends had said, and she started to wonder what they could mean. And what exactly she could be walking into.
There were a number of possibilities, but if she was honest with herself, Hope knew exactly what this was. And she knew exactly what she wanted to happen next. Which only seemed to be increasingly likely, as they got closer and closer to their destination, and Josie looked behind her at the tribrid nervously. Meanwhile Lizzie was honestly just as nervous, even though she was trying desperately not to show it by never looking back. Then they reached their cell, which turned out to be empty. Which dramatically narrowed down the options of what her friends wanted. And as they turned to face her, Hope waited with baited breath to see what they would say next...
- 30
- 31
- 32
You need to be logged in to leave a review for this story.You need to be logged in to leave a review for this story.
Report Story

Gehanna