Adult-FanFiction.org : Buffy

Gehanna	By : MTLandLL Category: -Buffy the Vampire Slayer > FemmeSlash - Female/Female Views: 129025 -:- Recommendations : 3 -:- Currently Reading : 2
Disclaimer: We do not own BtVS, its characters or any of the other characters that appear in this story, they belong to others. We are not making any money from this story.

Chapter List
- 1-Gehanna
- 2-2
- 3-3
- 4-4
- 5-5
- 6-6
- 7-7
- 8-8
- 9-9
- 10-10
- 11-11
- 12-12
- 13-13
- 14-14
- 15-15
- 16-16
- 17-17
- 18-18
- 19-19
- 20-20
- 21-21
- 22-22
- 23-23
- 24-24
- 25-25
- 26-26
- 27-27
- 28-28
- 29-29
- 30-30
- 31-31
- 32-32
- 33-33
- 34-34
- 28
- 29
- 30
Disclaimer: I do not own BtVS or Legacies or Shadowhunters. I do not make any money from this story.
*****
"Well, that was interesting." Clary quipped, as she watched the girls who were in the van with her be led away, after one had blown a hole in the wall.
"It's not fair." Izzy grumbled.
"That too." Clary agreed, sadly.
"Do any of your abilities work?" Izzy asked, before confessing, "Because mine won't, and I don't have my Stele."
"Me neither." Clary said sadly, before smiling, "But we're not physically helpless, thanks to you."
Izzy preened, realizing that Clary was referring to her teaching her to fight, and then suggested, "Shall we take a look around?"
"Sure..." Clary agreed hesitantly, before quipping, "It doesn't look like we're getting a tour guide."
Clary Fray and Isabelle Lightwood then held hands as they walked into the large building they would find out was called Gehanna, or Prison Butt Fuck. It definitely lived up to the latter name, as before they even reached the doors they saw women fooling around with each other. And then, God, it was everywhere. Everywhere they went in the prison women were doing the most obscene things with each other, right there in the open. Which made both girls blush as red as Clary's hair, although it didn't go unnoticed that the brunette's eyes lingered on whatever those women were doing. Even the most extreme of things. Not that it was a surprise. No, Isabelle Lightwood had been sexually confident ever since they had met, and were never shy about expressing her interest for men, or women.
Honestly Clary was half expecting Izzy to abandon her the first chance she got. And she got plenty of chances, given they were propositioned constantly. Mostly it was friendly enough, the women disappointed when they were turned down, but they didn't get aggressive about it. And when one or two did, it led to a short fight, which the Shadowhunters won easily. Clary wasn't surprised Izzy didn't go for those 'offers', but there were perfectly nice girls throwing themselves at her best friend. Not that she was going to complain. No, she was happy when her only friend didn't abandon her as they made their way through this strange place. However, after they found an empty cell which they could call their own, the redhead felt compelled to let the brunette know she was supportive.
"You know..." Clary began awkwardly, "If, if you want to, you know, it's okay with me."
"What?" Izzy frowned distractedly.
"If you want to go out, and... and have fun." Clary pushed with a blush.
"Oh..." Izzy murmured as realization hit, and then she cautiously asked, "Do... do you want too?"
"No!" Clary shot down quickly, before quickly adding, "But I know that you swing that way, so..."
"That doesn't mean that I'm just going to leave you." Izzy said softly, and then promising, "I would never do that."
"I know." Clary smiled softly, then pointed out, "But you wouldn't have to go far, and I'm sure I'd be fine here. Thanks to you."
Isabelle stared at Clary for a few long seconds, with a strange look on her face, then reassured, "There, there is nowhere else I'd rather be."
Clary wasn't sure she believed her, but she smiled and said, "Okay."
"Okay." Izzy said softly, then after a long pause she took a deep breath and cautiously asked, "So, wanna snuggle?"
"Always." Clary beamed.
It probably made them look weak, or whatever, but Clary didn't care, she was so happy that she was still going to get snuggles. She had warned Izzy she had a habit of doing that when she slept with someone, in the literal sense. The first time had been the mission where they had to stay overnight somewhere with only one bed. Thankfully Isabelle hadn't minded, and ever since then it had been kind of a habit. Mostly because Isabelle Lightwood had the biggest pair of tits Clary had ever seen in real life, and they made the perfect pillows. And she just liked cuddling with her best friend. It just felt so normal, and right. Not that she would know, given that Izzy had been her first, and so far only, female friend. But the other girl never complained, so it had to be normal. Right?
Whatever the case, it was something that the two of them did a lot of over the next few days. Sure, they found plenty of cells with two beds, but they could have been occupied. Besides, they like their snuggles. Also, that wasn't their main concern. No, their main goal was to escape, and find a way back to their world. Because, thanks to gathering information, they found out this was an alternative universe. They'd had experience with those before. Or at least Clary had, and there must be a way back. Although Izzy seemed increasingly tightly wound, and she kept looking at Clary expectantly for some reason. She of course asked what was wrong, only this time, she wouldn't be dismissed.
"What?" Clary questioned, trying and failing to hide her annoyance as she pushed, "And don't say nothing, again. Something is clearly bothering you, so tell me. You know you can tell me anything, right? I'm supposed to be your best friend. For God sakes Izzy, I'm your Parabatai. You seriously didn't think I don't know something's wrong?"
"You didn't notice before." Izzy grumbled softly.
"What do you mean?" Clary frowned, then after a few long seconds adding, "Seriously, what? I'm not going to drop this. Not again. So you might as well tell me."
There was a brief pause, and then Izzy bit her lip, and asked softly, "Do... do you feel different?"
"Different, how?" Clary frowned.
"I don't know." Izzy lied.
There was a long pause, then against her better judgment Clary grumbled, "I haven't been turned into a complete lesbian slut, obsessed with sticking things in places they shouldn't be."
"Oh... goodie?" Izzy raised an eyebrow.
"Not that there's anything wrong with it. I mean, if that's what you're into." Clary quickly added, "I just don't see the appeal of something being shoved, you know, up there."
"Maybe you'd be surprised." Izzy grinned seductively.
"Maybe?" Clary blushed, trying not to look at her friend directly.
Izzy bit her lip, and then carefully moved closer to her best friend, and the bed they were sharing, and asked, "So... to be clear, you don't see the appeal of anal. But you see the appeal of lesbian sex?"
"Yes." Clary said without hesitation, still not looking at Izzy.
"Why?" Izzy gently pushed.
There was a long pause, then Clary took a deep breath, glanced up at her friend, and admitted, "I... I like girls?"
Izzy grinned excitedly, "Really?"
"Yeah." Clary said sheepishly.
"Because of the magic in this place, or..." Izzy asked, wishing she didn't have to check.
"Or." Clary admitted softly.
"But..." Izzy asked with a frown, and then asked, "But why didn't you say anything?"
"You never asked." Clary pointed out.
There was another pause, then Izzy asked, "So, do you want to go out and see if we can find a girl to share?"
"No." Clary said.
"How about one each?" Izzy pushed.
"No!" Clary insisted, "You can, if you want, but I..."
"What?" Izzy pushed again.
"Because I don't want my first time with a girl to be with some rando I don't care about. I want it to be with you!" Clary blurted out what she had been holding in for years, but especially over the past few days, which was pretty much a nightmare for her, which ended the worst way possible, namely with Isabelle Lightwood laughing at her. Although not for the reason she thought in that moment, as she softly questioned, "Izzy?"
"I'm sorry, I'm sorry, it's just... we're both idiots." Izzy said, as she desperately tried to get herself under control.
"What?" Clary questioned.
"Oh, Clarissa Adele Fairchild, I've wanted you the second I saw you, and every single day you made me fall for you a little bit more." Izzy finally confessed, her words becoming more lustful as she glanced down at Clary's amazing body and added "Especially in this place, where I have nothing to distract me from how bad I want to tear off your clothes and fuck you."
One last brief pause, then Clary confessed, "Me too. I wanted you from the start, but I was scared, and still figuring myself out. Deep down I knew I liked girls, but it was easier to be straight. Especially when I had Jace, and then Simon, and then Jace again, but you were the one who brought back my memories, and I realized this whole time I had been falling for you. No, I always knew I was falling for you, but you talked about boys more than you did girls, and you always seem to have someone too, and I was just scared to lose you, and there never seem to be good time to tell you. And, and then we got here, and I didn't want to have sex, if it would be meaningless to you."
Isabelle and Clary had been staring into each other's eyes towards the end there, and the brunette felt like she must literally have cartoon heart eyes for the redhead at this point. By The Angel, she wanted to interrupt, but it was such a beautiful speech, she just had to hear every word of it. Then when Clary finally trailed off, breaking her heart with that last comment, Izzy grabbed hold of that beautiful face, and pulled her friend into a deep, passionate kiss. It was pretty much everything she thought kissing Clarissa Adele Fairchild would be, except for the fact that she would force herself to fall back after only a minute or so, because she needed to say one more thing.
"Please Clary, let me show you how not meaningless to me this would be." Izzy pleaded.
"Okay." Clary smiled softly.
For a few long seconds Izzy returned that soft smile before smashing their lips together again in another deep and passionate kiss. However, unlike the first it was sweet and romantic, and more desperately needy and rough. Also, Izzy pinned Clary down onto the bed, only for her friend to switch their positions, much to her delight. She was even more delighted by the fact that they kept switching at that point, while allowing just enough time to appreciate each position. Which would hopefully be the case when they moved on to other things, although for once Isabelle Lightwood was in no hurry to get there. No, she was perfectly happy to spend hours kissing Clary Fray just like this. Especially if it meant feeling up that cute little body of her petite friend.
Although to her delight, it was actually Clary who began the groping. Namely by grabbing onto Izzy's big tits, and giving them a nice, firm squeeze. The type of which that made Izzy chuckle into the kiss, and quickly return the favour, with her best friend's smaller, but very perky titties. Which made the brunette even more sad than the redhead hadn't taken her up on her generous offer to make the same alterations to their ugly prison uniforms that she had. Because seriously, how did it make sense for a prison encouraging lesbian sex not to feature cleavage? Because sure, it led to a few more unwanted advances, but nothing she wasn't use to receiving from men. And fuck, having Clary Fray reaching under her shirt and cupping her tits totally made it worth it.
Normally this would be the part where Izzy would be pulling away, and insisting on giving a nice, long, drawn-out striptease. But, admittedly, not for the first time, she could pull herself away from the pair of lips in front of her. So she did her best to strip herself and the other girl without tearing anything. Luckily, she had plenty of practice with this. This was special, so her hands trembled a little, but she was just about able to do it. Which allowed for more touching of bare flesh. This was extra wonderful when Clary grabbed her ass. Because sure, she had been hesitant about ass play before, but maybe she wouldn't mind if it was someone else's booty? Oh please, let that be the case, Izzy silently prayed, as she really wanted to be butt fucked by this amazing girl.
Clary was so overwhelmed by this wonderful moment, that she didn't really think that through until after she had done it. Which made her blush furiously, and tense up a bit, something that the brunette quickly took advantage of, just by moving her lips down to the redhead's neck, and while she began to kiss it, that gave Clary a chance to think about what she had been implying. She still wasn't sure about anal sex... but if she was going to do something like that, it would definitely have to be with Isabelle Lightwood's ridiculously perfect booty. Because seriously, this woman was a goddess made flesh, with curves in all the right places, which just made everyone's mouth water. Very much including hers.
However, there was one place more than Izzy's butt which Clary was interested in, and she spent most of that kiss indulging in it. Which was of course, namely Isabelle's gigantic boobs, which felt oh so good in Clary's hands. Even better than she had imagined. And she wanted to do more with them. Everything, really. But for better or for worse, Izzy totally beat her to it. Oh yes, her best female friend eventually moved her lips downwards again, and gave the redhead's tits the same thing she had been giving her neck. Namely kissing all over that soft flesh, before concentrating on one part in particular. Although this time, it was pretty obvious what area the brunette went for each time. Something that was hard to argue with, because again, it felt so good, but it wasn't what she really wanted in that moment.
So after a few long seconds, Clary flipped the positions, so she was the one who got to wrap her lips around a nipple, and started frantically licking and sucking it. Well, admittedly she may have used a little too much force in the beginning, but it wasn't like Izzy complained about that. No, the other girl chuckled wickedly, then started stroking her long ginger hair, and cooing in encouragement. Which of course, had Clary preening, and then moving over to the other nipple to give it the same treatment. Only this time, she made sure to kiss the surrounding flesh. Worshiping those big titties as they deserved to be worshiped. And, and she just couldn't resist, a few times pressing her face deep in between those giant tits, and rubbed her face in them. Oh God, she motor-boated another girl's boobs!
Thankfully this made the bad ass Isabelle Lightwood, who had effortlessly kicked the asses of men for less, just chuckle wickedly, and teased her, "By The Angel Clary, you're worse than a guy! I love it, though. Mmmmmmmmmmm yesssssssssssss, mmmmmmmmm, I love it when pretty little things like you go crazy for my tits. When girls love my boobs as much as guys do. Oh yes, it's so hot. Especially with you, Clary. Ah fuck, mmmmmmmmmmm, ooooooooooooooh fuck, I've wanted to see you lez out for so long. To lez out with you. Ohhhhhhhhhhhh shit, please do whatever you want to me, sweetie. I'm yours! Mmmmmmmmmm yeahhhhhhhhhhhhh, fuck me however you want."
Which had Clary blushing furiously. Both at these words, and at her own actions. It was hard to tell which was more embarrassing, or hot. And honestly, it didn't really matter at that moment. No, all that mattered was being able to worship these big titties, like she had wanted to do since she first saw them. God, she really just wanted to worship them forever. Or at least the rest of the night. Or day, or whatever time it was. It was hard to tell, but again, it didn't matter. What mattered, was that clearly Izzy wanted more. And while she didn't want to move away from those big tits, so did Clary. The question was, what should they do about it? Something which she thought about it for a few long seconds, before coming to a conclusion which would be good for them both of them. Now she just needed to force words out. Which was easier said than done.
. Something which was clear when Clary pulled back and bit her lip, causing Izzy to raise an eyebrow in question, "My turn?"
"I..." Clary blushed, struggling to meet her friend's eyes.
"Or we can stop, if you really want." Izzy quickly added, before admitting, "But I hope not, because I really want to suck your titties. And eat your pretty little pussy. And... well, everything. I want to do everything with you, Clary Fray. Please let me? Please, mmmmmmmmmm, just lay back, and I'll..."
"I wanna 69!" Clary blurted out, blushed again, and then questioned while Izzy just grinned up at her, "If that's okay?"
""Hell yes, it's okay." Izzy laughed with wicked delight, quickly pushing, "Mmmmmmmmm fuck yes, sit on my face, Clary Fray. Or let me sit on yours. Mmmmmmmmmm yesssssssssss, let's 69, like proper little lesbian lovers. Ooooooooooooooh yesssssssssssss, my lesbian lover, Clary. Give me your pussy. I wanna 69 with you! Oh yes, ohhhhhhhhhhhhh fuck yeah, give it to me!"
Izzy tried not to get carried away with her enthusiasm for this idea, although restraint had never been her strong suit. Thankfully, after a few long seconds of continuing to bite her lip adorably, Clary slowly turned her body around on top of her, so that her cute little cunt was hovering over Izzy's mouth. Which naturally shut the more experienced Shadowhunter up, and she just grinned, and stared in wonder at the prize in front of her. The prize which was slowly lowered downwards, onto her eagerly awaiting lips. Oh God, the anticipation killed her, but for once Isabelle Lightwood forced herself to be patient, as she didn't want to scare Clary off, when she was so close to getting what she wanted.
However, once Clary's cute little cunt was pressing against her lips, Izzy reached up and grabbed two handfuls of well-rounded cheeks, and held them firmly in place. The plan was that she would let go, or maybe, just relax her grip, now that she was actually getting to feel those cheeks in her hands. Point being, that eventually she would give her friend the chance to pull away, if that was what she really wanted. But for now, she was determined to hold her in place. Oh yes, Clary Fray wasn't going anywhere for a few long seconds. Not until she found out exactly what Isabelle Lightwood could do with her, with just a few strokes of her tongue. And of course, before Izzy got a decent taste of the other girl's pussy.
Which again, was every bit as good as she had imagined it to be, moans, gasps and whimpers in pure pleasure just falling out of Izzy's lips as that flavour hit her taste-buds. Which in turn, were drowned out by the similar sounds Clary was making. As she should. Oh yes, Izzy prided herself on being good at every aspect of sex, and she never wanted to please anyone more than right now. So the fact that she seemed to be succeeding made her heart flutter with happiness. And of course, love for this wonderful girl. And love for the taste of pussy. Especially this pussy. Something which just echoed in her mind in one form or another for the next few minutes, as she was pretty overwhelmed by the heaven which was having Clary Fray sitting on her face.
It was so wonderful that Izzy would happily stay in this position for the rest of the night, without receiving anything in return. Hell, she might just cum from the sheer mental high that she was receiving right now, which went double when she inevitably made Clary Fray cum in her mouth, and all over her face. And even if she didn't, all it would take was a hand playing with her pussy while that was happening to finish the job. Of course, she was very glad it didn't come to that. Oh yes, it understandably took a few minutes, but Izzy very much welcomed when Clary started to return the favour. Which just like everything else, completely blew her expectations out of the water, and made this whole experience that much more wonderful.
Clary threw her head back and let out a loud cry of pleasure the first time she felt another girl's tongue touching her twat, which was a completely overwhelming experience for her. Especially considering it was Isabelle Lightwood doing this to her, and she was focusing on that ridiculously gorgeous face in between her legs while doing it. Oh yes, it was so overwhelming that she forgot about returning the favour, and just stayed rooted to the spot for a few long seconds. Which admittedly, was probably a good thing, as there would've been no way that she could have actually done anything in that moment. Although that didn't stop her from feeling guilty about it. Even if there was a very easy way she could make it up to her best female friend.
On the bright side, in all this excitement her hands had shot to Izzy's big tits again, allowing for her to at least give some enjoyment to the other girl. Although admittedly, Clary was still probably benefiting from this the most, given that she just couldn't get enough of those big boobs. Which was a very positive sign, given what she was about to do. It was still pretty nerve-racking, given this was her first time with a woman. But Clary was reminded that she had dreamed of this, both consciously and unconsciously, to the point where there was no way she could be 100% straight. Oh yes, she was totally gay for Isabelle Lightwood's giant titties, and hopefully she would be just as gay for Isabelle Lightwood's pussy.
While it took an embarrassingly long time to work up the courage to bend her head downwards, stick out her tongue, and slid it over the other girl's pussy, Clary was instantly relieved to find out that she was. Oh yes, she was totally gay for pussy. Or at least, Isabelle Lightwood's pussy. Something she proved as she let out a long, loud moan into the tasty treat in front of her. Which she knew from experience, only added to the enjoyment, thanks to the vibrations. Something that she was reminded of as Izzy moaned too, and let out other sounds of enjoyment throughout the 69 moving forward which caused Clary to let out similar sounds, creating a wonderful chain reaction which upped the pleasure for both of them.
At the same time, it was clear that Izzy was trying to hold back, which made Clary's heart flutter. Oh yes, it was clear that the brunette wanted to take her time with this, both to savour it herself, and ultimately, give the redhead as much pleasure as possible. And Clary wanted to think the same thing, so she was only too happy to follow Izzy's lead, which led to a nice, long, slow pussy licking. Which was pure heaven, and yet at the same time, increasingly torture, because she wanted more, and she could tell, so did her friend. It was now just a question of how much could the other take before ultimately it would all become too much, and she would make the other girl cum. Which could be a real problem, given that because of their competitive nature, it was unsurprising they didn't want to be the first one to crack.
Izzy was also enjoying the irony of that, but honestly, she would take it over the alternative. Because really, she had been half expecting Clary to make her cum as quickly as possible, her nervousness and inexperience getting the better of her. Or more likely, just be too scared to do anything, and leaving the more experienced girl to do all the work. Which again, the brunette would have welcomed, as she truly loved the redhead, and considered just getting to worship her pretty little pussy a blessing. But she definitely welcomed what she was experiencing now, because it was the best possible outcome. Oh yes, it was a sign that Clary Fray was actually enjoying herself, and wanted to give Izzy the most amount of pleasure possible. And really, who could say no to that?
But because of their competitive nature, and maybe, just because the redhead became lost in this act, it was ultimately, the brunette who pushed things forwards. Another factor was Clary's inexperience, as she ended up copping everything that Izzy ended up doing to her. Like an increasing attention to the other girl's clit. Oh yes, at first Izzy stayed away from that, so she could savour the pleasure, but ultimately she went forwards, going from ignoring it, to touching it with every lick. Then she was taking it into her mouth, and sucking on it, while manoeuvring a hand in between Clary's legs, so she could rub the other girl's entrance, while she focused up on her clit. All of which, her fellow Shadowhunter copied, and then some.
Every time there was an addition Clary picked it up as fast as everything else. Oh yes, Clarissa Fairchild had always been a wonderfully fast learner, and Izzy was never happier with that than right now. And the fact that Clary not only learned the lessons fast, but then started doing things which Isabelle hadn't even thought of yet. Well, in this case, Izzy had definitely thought of them, she just hadn't shown her friend how to do it, yet. Which was very promising for the future, but it didn't really fix the present. The one which they were in a stalemate, and ultimately one of them needed to make the other cum first. And how it ended up happening was somewhat surprised to her. Namely, by Clary rubbing her face against Izzy's cunt.
That had never made her cum before, but Clary just did it with such passion, and even love, and after everything that Izzy had been through before this, she just couldn't stop herself from cumming. Oh yes, Isabelle Lightwood had been accused by her brothers of being horny all the time, but who could blame her when people as hot as Clary Fray were constantly around her? And that was even more true ever since she ended up in Gehanna, where women did unspeakable things to each other. And oh fuck, then there was the fact that she was in a 69 with Clary Fray right now, and doing a wonderful job at it, making sure that ultimately when she came it was easily one of the hardest and most satisfying climaxes of her life. So much so, that she actually stopped what she was doing for a few long seconds. Which was kind of heart-breaking, but she just couldn't stop herself.
Clary was glad that attention to her pussy was momentarily halted, as it gave her a chance to concentrate on some of the heavenly liquid flowing into her mouth. Which wasn't easy, given the second that girl cum... Isabelle Lightwood's girl cum, hit her taste-buds, she was once again rendered unable to do anything, but savour the experience she was being treated too. As a result, a lot of that precious liquid ended up covering her face. But ultimately, that was a good thing, because while she didn't get to swallow it, it marked her as what she was, a slut for this heavenly treat. And more importantly, Izzy's. Oh yes, in a weirdly primal way, Isabelle Lightwood was marking Clary as hers, and the redhead loved her for it.
She also loved the fact that she got to return the favour, and mark the brunette as hers. Cum all over the ridiculously beautiful face of Isabelle Lightwood, and in her pretty little mouth, meaning that they had marked each other. Maybe even made each other theirs. Oh yes, Clary loved that thought. Which was her last coherent one for quite a while, as she became consumed with swallowing as much as that precious girl cum as she could, and more importantly, making the woman she loved cum as much as possible. Which was pretty easy now, given the flood gates were open, for both of them, but it still gave them plenty of chances to experiment with things they hadn't done with each other before, especially for the inexperienced girl.
Which involve things like shoving tongues and fingers into pussies, and fucking the other girl with it. Oh God yes, Clary got to tongue fuck another girl. To feel Isabelle Lightwood use her tongue, and then her fingers, as she gave this goddess of a woman another powerful climax. And then just when she didn't think it could get any better, it did when a finger was shoved into her ass hole. Under other circumstances, Clary might've been upset about that, but in her current state of mind, the redhead didn't even think about complaining. No, instead she set about returning the favour, AKA, pulling cum covered fingers out of a cunt, and shoving it into another girl's butt hole, causing that girl to cum for her, yet again.
Being Shadowhunters, they were able to do this for a ridiculous amount of time. Which was mostly a good thing, although it did leave Clary feeling more exhausted than she had ever done before, when she finally rolled off of Izzy, and that was really saying something, given all their adventures. And yet, her best female friend ever somehow found the strength to turn around, and jump on top of her again, forcing their ridiculously over stimulated bodies to press against each other again. Something which was impossible for Clary to complain about, given that Izzy then kissed her passionately, allowing both of them to taste their own cum and pussy cream on each other's lips and tongues, and deep inside the other's mouth.
Even though this 'only' lasted several minutes, it felt like it could have been even longer, if it wasn't for an unfamiliar voice questioning teasingly, "Oh, I do hope we're not interrupting?"
Reluctantly Clary broke the kiss, and glared at the girls standing in the doorway, "You are, and you know it."
"True, but hopefully it will be a good interruption." Lizzie grinned, "One we all will enjoy."
"What my friend means is, hi." Hope greeted, before introducing herself and the others, "I'm Hope Mikaelson, and this is Josie and Lizzie Saltzman. Oh, and that's Dawn Summers. She's just a slut, but the three of us are butt busting tops, who work for Willow Rosenberg, who if you haven't heard, is the Alpha female of this prison, and basically runs it."
"We know who you are." Clary grumbled.
"We've seen you around." Izzy grinned, seeing where this was going, and then asking hopefully, "So, is there a position you'd like to offer us in your little girl group?"
"Yes, actually." Hope grinned back, "Mistress Willow has seen deep into your hearts, and minds, and think you have great potential as anal loving bottoms. I know, I know, your bad ass demon hunters, or whatever, and you fancy yourself a switch, but seriously, have you seen your asses? Mmmmmmmmm, they were both made to be fucked."
""And the only real reason you haven't been getting butt fucked on the daily, isn't because you're so tough." Lizzie revealed gleefully, "No, it's because Mistress Willow was nice enough to hold everyone back, or at least everyone back who would listen, and allow the two of you to work your feelings out for each other first."
"Of course, you don't have to do anything you don't want too." Josie chimed in firmly, giving her sibling a look.
"Right..." Lizzie said, trying to leave it there, and failing, "But why waste time? You both know what you want, especially that big booty brunette there. Mmmmmmmm yeahhhhhhhhhh, you both want a big dick in the ass, so why wait? Don't you want to know what all the fuss is about? Haven't you waited long enough to take a Gehanna butt fucking?"
"If you want, we can come back later. Or you can find us, when you're ready. Or just stick to traditional lesbian love making. I can definitely see the appeal of that. Especially when the two of you are together. But..." Hope quickly added, moving closer to Clary and addressing her directly, "Don't you think that's a little selfish of you, Clarissa Fairchild?"
"How, how do you know my name?" Clary asked weakly.
"Our Alpha can read minds. And so can we, given the right spell." Hope revealed, again moving forward, and softly telling her new friend, "But you shouldn't need to be a mind reader to tell that Isabelle Lightwood is desperate to get fucked in the ass. I mean, just look at her? Look at the way she's looking at us? You know why she's held back this long, don't you? So why keep denying her, if you're not going to do it?"
There was a brief pause, then Clary looked over at her best friend and new lover and asked her, "Is that true, Izzy?"
"Fuck yes." Izzy replied with hesitation, then quickly added, "But I love you, Clary. I love you with all my heart, I promise you, that's enough for me. But... if you could fuck my ass, that would be amazing. Or, we could both get fucked? That would be amazing too. Just think about it. I can prepare you by getting that cute little ass of yours ready. Swirl my tongue around your hot little butt hole, mmmmmmmmm, munch your fucking butt until your begging someone, anyone, to fuck your needy little booty. Just like me. Because I think they're right, Clary. Ooooooooooh yesssssssss, you could totally make a great top, if you wanted. We both could. But why waste time trying to top, when bottoms get the most pleasure?"
Another brief pause, then Clary stammered, "I, I... I don't know."
"How about we sweeten the deal?" Hope offered, "Obviously, if you don't like it, we can stop at any time, but if you like it, at the end will give you a choice. Either you can be our exclusive property, and we'll take care of all your anal needs, while letting you fuck each other as much as you want. Or, you can be sluts, who bend over for anyone and everyone in this prison. Or just go back to playing with each other."
"Sounds like a pretty sweet deal to me." Izzy beamed.
"Isn't it, though?" Lizzie beamed.
"But it's up to you." Josie reminded Clary.
Yet another brief pause, then Clary pointed out, "But... I don't even know you."
"Isn't that part of the charm?" Hope pointed out, "Giving up your virgin ass to someone you've just met?"
"Or a slutty little ass?" Lizzie beamed.
"Oh, it is." Izzy beamed before against her better judgment, pleading, "Could you just try it this once, for me? Please Clary?"
"Okay, fine." Clary said after the longest pause yet, "But you owe me."
"Yessssssssss!" Izzy celebrated, before pushing with a wicked grin, "And hell yeah I do. Mmmmmmmmm, and I'm going to start making it up to you right now, by eating that sweet little ass of yours. Ohhhhhhhhhhhh yeahhhhhhhhhhh, bend over, Clary. Bend over and let me tongue your perfect little butt hole, and get it nice and ready for these women to fuck."
Izzy knew that she was pushing her luck, but she couldn't help it. She had always been a greedy bitch, and after literally years of repressing her feelings for Clary, she felt like she could no longer hold herself back, and wanted to do everything possible with this goddess of a woman right now. Hell, a big part of her wanted to be the one to fuck Clary's perfect little ass, and she almost insisted on it when the blushing redhead finally turned onto her stomach, and then lifted her mouth-watering booty into the air for Izzy to lick. And she was tempted again throughout eating that heavenly bottom, but deep down Isabelle knew this was for the best. After all, she just wasn't confident she could give Clarissa Fairchild the butt fucking she so richly deserved.
There was just something about the newcomers which told her they would do a better job than her. Although if she was proven wrong Isabelle just might insist on trying it herself. Or find someone who could, like the infamous Mistress Willow. Whatever it takes, because Clary Fray and her amazing booty deserved only the best. Something she felt even more strongly about when she finally pulled apart those cheeks, and then spent a few more long seconds staring at the prize in front of her with wonder and delight. Then, with a big smile on her face, which was probably there throughout the night, Isabelle lightwood leaned down, stuck out her tongue, and slid it over Clarissa Fairchild's butt hole, causing both Shadowhunters to cry out joyfully.
Sounds which were repeated over and over again as Izzy repeated that lick, initially just sticking to sliding her tongue up and down that cute little butt hole, but eventually swirling her tongue around it, just as she promised. If it was just the two of them, Izzy might have taken her time to give that perfect bottom the worshipping it deserved, but as she knew there were a bunch of girls eager to ass fuck them, she picked things up sooner rather than later. Namely, by trying to push her tongue into Clary's heavenly booty. Unsurprisingly she didn't get very far, but she got a little bit in, and that was enough for her to technically be the first to fuck Clary Fray's butt. It deserved so much more than this, and it would get it, but it was nice to think that she had contributed.
About the same time Izzy felt a tongue touching her back door, with the obvious difference being that she didn't know who's tongue it was. Not that she cared at this point. No, any of these hotties could rim her, and she would be cool with it. Especially as she was about to take a butt fucking, so a rim job definitely seemed like a good idea right now. Both giving, and receiving. And hell, it was really, really good, whoever it was not hesitating to shove that talented little tongue of hers deep into Izzy's big booty. She also didn't bother spreading the cheeks, instead suffocating herself in that fat ass, no doubt providing great stimulation for both of them. Which was really saying something, considering that right now, Isabelle was busy eating Clary Fray's delicious little bottom.
"Okay girls, that's enough of that." Hope said softly and gleefully, and then louder and somewhat angrier, "I said that's enough!"
"Sorry, Mistress Hope." Dawn whimpered, quickly removing her face from Izzy's fat ass.
"Sorry, Mistress Hope." Clary moaned, just in case she was supposed too, even though she did nothing to push Izzy away from her.
Then, a few long seconds later, Izzy reluctantly pulled her mouth away from Clary's cute little ass hole, and teasingly replied, "Sorry, Mistress Hope."
"Sorry is not good enough..." Lizzie growled, smacking Izzy's fat booty hard enough to make the cheeks jiggle, and then warned her, "Do better next time."
"Ah fuck..." Izzy cried out, momentarily glaring at Lizzie. The Shadowhunter had broken bones for less, but in this case, she just smiled flirtatiously, and replied without a hint of sincerity, "Sorry, Mistress... Whatever Your Name Was. Oooooooooooh, I really, really, hope you don't have to spank me for being naughty. I would hate that sooooooooooooo much."
Lizzie glared at the sarcasm, and then smirked, "Well, I can just wait for my turn for Clary's sweet ass, and just leave you to watch the other bottoms get what they want."
"No! No, please, anything but that." Izzy pleaded, afraid that the other girl meant it, "I'm sorry Mistress... Mistress..."
"Mistress Lizzie." Dawn chimed in helpfully.
"Mistress Lizzie." Izzy continued, "I'm sorry Mistress Lizzie, mmmmmmmmm, please fuck my ass. Pleasssssssse? I'm a slut, who hasn't taken it up the butt in weeks."
"Weeks, huh? Wow, no wonder you're so bitchy." Lizzie grinned, smacking that big booty with both hands, and then greedily groping it, "Oh yes, you're totally forgiven, because an ass like this should be legally required to be fucked on a daily basis. Yeahhhhhhhhhhh, you going without a butt fucking with a booty like this for so long should be against the law. In fact, I'm pretty sure it is in a place like this. But don't worry, because Mistress Lizzie is here now. Oooooooooooooh yesssssssssssss, Mistress Lizzie, Mistress Josie and Mistress Hope are going to make sure that this big fat ass gets all the fucking it deserves. And same for your little girlfriend, with the clearly made for fucking ass!"
"Ohhhhhhhhhh, thank you Mistress Lizzie. Please use my ass whenever you want." Izzy moaned dreamily.
"Getting back on track..." Hope grumbled, "Can the three bottoms line up, and spread their cheeks, please? Ohhhhhhhhhhh yeahhhhhhhhhh, I wanna see three pretty little bitch asses, all in a row."
"Yes, Mistress Hope." Dawn quickly replied and obeyed.
"Yes, Mistress Hope." Izzy quickly replied and obeyed, although sadly, this meant moving away from Mistress Lizzie's greedy hands.
"Yes, Mistress Hope." Clary whimpered, even though that the other girls moved closer to her, which was good, because it took all her courage for her to spread her cheeks and wait to be robbed of her anal cherry.
Hope and the twins took a moment to admire the prizes in front of them, and then they kneeled down behind those prizes, stroking lube into their magically quipped strap-ons. The same magic which allowed Hope to leave them in just their strap-ons, meaning there was a pretty good view to her left and right as well. Luckily it was pretty easy to concentrate on that beautiful sight in front of her, especially as she was dealing with a virgin ass hole. Because of that, she gently pushed a lubed up finger into Clary's cute little back door, causing the other girl to gasp and moan softly, as her ass was penetrated, stuffed and then fucked by something much more than what she had probably been expecting in that moment.
The other bottoms let out similar sounds as they got similar treatment. It was probably unnecessary for Izzy, given her enthusiasm for all of this, but it was still quite a treat to see Lizzie slide one finger into that slutty little ass hole with the greatest of ease. Hell, she was even able to get a second and there, just as easily. Meanwhile, Dawn had been wearing a butt-plug, meaning Josie just had to grab onto it, pull it out, and have her way with the shameless butt slut. However, it seemed that Josie could wait for the rest of them to catch up. Or maybe she and her sister were waiting for Hope to make the first move, as it meant taking a back door cherry? Whatever the case, Dawn was gently sodomized with that plug for a few long minutes, something she clearly loved, while craving more.
Deciding it was time for more Hope pulled out her finger, and gently sucked it clean while pressing the tip of her cock against her target. Understandably, that caused Clary to flinch, but she forced herself to relax before anyone could say anything. Hope considered saying something anyway, but that would've been patronizing, so instead she chose to slowly push forwards, causing that forbidden hole to stretch wider and wider, and wider for the invading object. About the same time the butt-plug was pulled out of Dawn's ass hole and the finger from Izzy's back door, the twins cleaning that butt cream as they too took aim, albeit slow, so they could savour the sight of their best friend taking an anal cherry.
It wasn't something that Hope could have ever imagined herself doing, or enjoying so much, but fuck, it was pure heaven. Maybe especially when that virgin back door stretched wide enough for the head of that big dick to slide through it and into Clary's cherry back door, making it official, Hope had just taken another girl's anal virginity. And she just met this girl. Oh fuck, she just met this girl, and yet, she would be forever the first one up this perfect little booty. The first of many. Oh yes, Clary Fray had a booty which should be pounded on a daily basis, and Hope was going to do everything in her power to make sure that it got what it deserved. And she was sure that the Saltzman twins would be only too happy to help her. And Mistress Willow, for that matter.
Isabelle, Clary and Dawn all cried out when they were anally penetrated. The difference was that the anal virgin cried out in pure pain, which was understandable given this was her first time, while the two butt sluts cried out with pure joy. Well admittedly, there was a significant amount of pain, at least for Izzy, given that she hadn't been butt fucked in a while. Too long, if she was being honest. But in an extremely twisted way, that pain added to her enjoyment, which was saying a lot, given everything going on around her. Meanwhile, she wondered if Dawn even felt pain at this point, given how frequently she had seen her take it up the ass. And if she would reach a stage where she felt nothing but pure pleasure from being anally taken.
Honestly, Izzy hoped so. Many had accused her of being a slut back in her world, but the truth was, she'd always been holding back. Could have always been much sluttier. And now finally, she had found a place which celebrated her constant need for sex, and she was fully ready to embrace it. To be the shameless slut she had always wanted to be. Well, she'd have to stick to just one gender, and maybe a preference for a really twisted act, but there was lots of fun to be had with that. Especially with Clary by her side. although that was under threat right now, given that her friend turned so much more was struggling to adjust, Izzy genuinely hoping to help with that As she offered encouraging words.
"You did it, Clary. Mmmmmmmmm yessssssssssss, you just gave up your butt cherry, for me." Izzy beamed, leaned in closer to her best friend, and made her blush as red as her hair, "By The Angel, I'm so proud of you. Mmmmmmmmmm yeahhhhhhhhhhh, I'm so proud of you for giving up your anal virginity to please me. To please the superior women. Ah fuck, ooooooooooh, feels good, doesn't it? Yes, I know it hurts, especially the first time, but there's nothing like the mental high of surrendering completely to someone else. Giving up your most private hole. Letting them totally dominant you. Make you their bitch. Their anal loving little bitch with a dick in her ass, ohhhhhhhhhhhhhh yeahhhhhhhhhhhh, fuck her! Fuck me, fuck me please? Oh God, AAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHH FUCKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK!"
Thankfully Izzy wasn't scolded for her words, and was in fact rewarded for them. Oh yes, Isabelle Lightwood got the one thing she really, really wanted in that moment, namely a cock pushed further up her slutty little ass, again causing them to cry out in mostly pleasure. Dawn too. Hell, there was even a cry pleasure from Clary, although Izzy liked to think that was at least partly because of her words. Whatever the case, either through a happy accident, or delightful intentions on her part, the redhead had her face positioned towards the brunette, who was only too happy to do the same, so that the two Shadowhunters could stare deep into each other's eyes throughout the initial butt sex.
Which allowed Izzy to press her forehead gently against Clary's, press kisses all over her face, and offer her words of encouragement as inch after inch of those cock slid deeper into their back passages, "Good girl, you're doing so well. Soooooooooooo well, mmmmmmmmmm fuck, it feels so good. I love it! Mmmmmmmmmm yeahhhhhhhhhh, I love it up the ass. And I want you to love it, Clary. I want you to love it as I do. Want us both to be anal loving whores, who can't get enough of taking it in the ass. Ohhhhhhhhhhhhhh yessssssssssss, of giving our asses up to other women. Superior women. Oooooooooooh yeahhhhhhhhh, that's what I want, oh yes, fuck me, ooooooooooooohhhhhhhhhhhhhh fuckkkkkkkkkkkk yeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeesssssssssssssss!"
Unsurprisingly the other Shadowhunter wasn't brave enough to reply, and many of those words made her blush with embarrassment. But then again, she would probably be blushing no matter what, if she was taking it up the butt, and hopefully this way her lover would distract her from the pain, and be aroused by her words. At the very least, it couldn't have hurt. Well, it couldn't have hurt Clary. Izzy meanwhile was almost painfully aroused, especially because these women took an infuriatingly long time to complete the ass stuffing. Although, she supposed that Mistress Lizzie and Mistress Josie were just following Mistress Hope's lead, and she was very glad that Mistress Hope was taking it easy on her sweet Clary. Especially given that, again, this was the first time for her and all.
Josie felt kind of bad for what she was doing to Dawn. Not the fact that she was sodomizing her. No, it was crystal-clear this girl lived to be fucked in the ass. But she was whimpering and whining, because the other brunette was doing this very slowly. Far slower than was necessary. True, Josie had never been one to bury the entire length of a dildo in any orifice, regardless of how slutty it was. Under other circumstances she would find a happy middle, but right now, it felt important to keep the same as the pace as Hope and Lizzie. And God knows the three of them had grown to love the experience of burying their cocks in three hot little holes at the same time. Even if it did have the tendency to make anal whores like Dawn and Faith whimper and whine with need.
Of course, no matter how nice and slowly they went, inevitably thighs came to rest against butt cheeks, announcing that the rectum stuffing was complete. That Hope, Lizzie and even Josie had buried every single inch of their strap-ons deep inside the asses of three little sluts. Oh yes, that was always an incredible treat. Although, as much as Josie liked Dawn, and loved sodomizing her, she couldn't help feel jealous of Lizzie and Hope right now. After all, they were experiencing the joy of some fresh ass meat. Especially in the case of the tribrid, who had just buried her dick up another girl's virgin ass. Another supernatural warrior's virgin ass, at that. One who once again received praise and encouragement from her little girlfriend.
"By The Angel, you did it Clary. We did it. Oooooooooooh yesssssssssss, mmmmmmmmm, that's every single inch up our butts. Up your cute little butt, mmmmmmmmm, and my big fat booty! Ah fuck, I'm so proud of you. Proud of us." Izzy beamed happily, quickly adding, "All of us. Oh yeah, you're doing good too, Dawn. Ohhhhhhhhhhh yeahhhhhhhhhh, we're all proving to be shameless little anal sluts, who love taking big dicks in our shit-pipes! Ohhhhhhhhhhhhh yesssssssssssss, fuck us. Fuck us in our slutty little asses! Ah fuck, fuck me! Butt fuck me, oooooooooooh yesssssssssss! Yessssssssssss, OOOOOOOOOOOOOOHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH YEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEESSSSSSSSSSSSSSS, FUCK US FUCK US HARD!"
Honestly, in that moment Josie was jealous of Clary for having someone who loved her so much. Was in love with her. And for Izzy, for having the same thing. Which made her glance over at Hope longingly. Of course, then first Hope, and then Lizzie started moving her hips back and forth, causing those dildos to slide in and out of the butt holes of Clary Fray and Isabelle Lightwood. Josie was also jealous of that, as the very thought made her own butt hole quiver in fear. Yes, there was part of her which was curious what it would be like, but mostly, she just wanted to top. To butt fuck the beautiful brunette in front of her. So that's what she did, while trying not to allow her mind to wander to anything else. Like the beautiful brunette beside her.
Admittedly throughout the sodomy she found herself looking over to Hope and Lizzie, and wishing she was in their places. God, Clary and Isabelle were so fucking hot, and it was amazing to see both of them take it up the butt side by side. But Josie would eventually get her turn with them. Both of them. She would make sure of that. For now though, she tried to be content with fucking Dawn's ass, which was spectacular in it's own right. However, she was the first to remove her dick from it, so she could get a piece of their new friends. Yes, it wasn't the hot little asses of the Shadowhunters, or big fat ass, in Izzy's case. It would be, however, quite the treat for them, given what it was the beginning of.
Which involved Josie pulling her cock out of Dawn's ass and moving around to the front, prompting Hope to question, "So, who wants to taste Dawnie's butt?"
"Ewww!" Clary replied, scrunching up her face in disgust.
Unsurprisingly, Izzy had a much different reaction, "Me, me, me! Mmmmmmmmmm, I'd love to taste Dawnie's butt. Please give it to me? Please? Oooooooooooooh yesssssssssss, mmmmmmmmm, I want to be a double stuffed whore for you. To take it in both ends. Ohhhhhhhhhhhh yeahhhhhhhhhhhh, double-team me like the fucking slut I am!"
"Well, it looks like we have a winner." Hope grinned, prompting her friend, "Josie?"
"Yes, Mistress Hope." Josie quickly replied and obeyed, those words supposed to be mocking, but they didn't come off that way, which was worrying for the siphon.
Dawn cried out with disappointment when the cock had been removed from her slutty little ass, but she comforted herself with knowing that it would soon be returned to her bowels. More importantly, she would be soon allowed the privilege of tasting girl butt. Hopefully her own first, and then the others. Sadly she was not the first to get that treat, and she whimpered when that became clear, and when Mistress Josie pushed her cock deep into the other new comer's eager little mouth. Although there was definitely something to be said for watching this, especially given how loudly and happily Isabelle Lightwood moaned at tasting Dawn's ass. Which was very promising for the future, in more ways than one.
It was further proof that the tops of Gehanna had gained themselves another great piece of ass, and in a way, so had Dawn. Especially if Isabelle hung around Mistress Willow and co. Oh yes, Dawn would be allowed to tongue that big, beautiful booty, and hopefully Isabelle would return the favour. Ideally Clary, too. And Dawn definitely wanted to slide her lips all over their amazing bodies, and sample everything they had to offer. Like the taste of their asses. Which Dawn was treated to after an eternity of being left alone. Or at least it felt that way. In reality, it was probably only a few minutes. At which point, Mistress Lizzie showed mercy on her, by pulling her big dick out of that big booty, walking around, and presenting it to the eager little ATM slut.
"Your turn, Dawnie." Lizzie ordered as she approached, "Mmmmmmmmm yesssssssssss, suck my cock. Ooooooooooooh yeahhhhhhhhhhh, suck it. Taste some new ass. Sorry it's not your own ass, I know you love that the best, but I'm sure you'll love this one too. Yes you will, yes you will, ohhhhhhhhhhh fuck yeah, suck it! Suck it just like that, oooooooooooooh yessssssssssss, mmmmmmmmmm, take it deep into your whore throat! Oh yes, get every single drop of Isabelle Lightwood's butt cream, you little ass to mouth whore! Ohhhhhhhhhhh fuck, be a good example for your fellow bottoms. Yeahhhhhhhhhh, show them how they should be sucking cock! Ah fuck yeah, just like that! Just like fucking that. Ooooooooooooohhhhhhhhhhhhh FUCK!"
"Yes, Mistress Lizzie. Thank you, Mistress Lizzie." Dawn eagerly replied and obeyed, not waiting until Mistress Lizzie was finished to do so.
Maybe Mistress Lizzie was worried about overwhelming Isabelle with too much of a good thing, but Dawn certainly wasn't about to complain. No, she wrapped her lips around the head of that dildo, and moaned loudly and happily. Just like Isabelle before her. As she should, given that the butt cream was predictably delicious. Dawn was even given plenty of time to savour it, and just when she didn't think it could get any better, it did. Well, technically she had hoped this would happen, but it was by no means guaranteed. But it happened. Oh yes, Mistress Josie returned her strap-on to Dawn's slutty little ass in the middle of that blow job, meaning that sweet little Dawn Summers was treated to a double fucking.
Sadly that spit roasting didn't last long, but it lasted long enough for Dawn to savour it. Savour the heaven of being taken in both ends, just like when Mistress Buffy and Mistress Willow would fuck her like that. Of course, it helped a lot that a blonde was involved in that equation, little Dawnie able to look upwards to see blonde hair, while she was busy stuffing that butt flavoured dildo into her throat, and her own butt was being stuffed full of strap-on. Then one of those cocks was taken away from her, and while she was glad that it wasn't the one in her ass, she knew it was only a matter of time before that one was taken away too. And sure enough it was, but she got to taste the asses of the other girls, and her own, so it was a fair trade. At least for now.
Clary couldn't believe what was happening. Any of it, really. It was just so gross, so disgusting, and so fucking hot. Even in the beginning, when she was an incredible pain from her most intimate area there was a weird kind of thrill to it. Especially given that Isabelle Lightwood was right next to her, actually fucking moaning happily from receiving this treatment. And bombarding the poor ginger with like the most twisted words ever. All of which added to her enjoyment, and helped Clary to relax, and get through the pain of the initial anal penetration and butt stuffing. Which wasn't even that bad, compared to some of the things which had happened to her ever since she found out she was a Shadowhunter.
The next thing she knew, she had taken the full length of that big strap-on cock up her ass, and another girl was sodomizing her. Oh God, she was being butt fucked by a girl she had just met, and it started to feel good. Then the two girls either side of her started going ass to mouth, which somehow turned her on even more, causing her to further relax, and for every ounce of pain to be replaced by pleasure. Something which Izzy noticed first, given she was closest to her, and she gave Clary a happy smile, even while her lips were busy wrapped around a cock, while another one was fucking her. Which just so happened to be the cock which had just been up Clary's butt, leaving the poor redhead alone, while the brunette got two cocks. Oh God, it hadn't been that long, but she wanted more.
Seeing the look on her face, Hope taunted her, "Awww, what's the matter, Clary? Do you miss getting your sweet little ass fucked? Mmmmmmmmm, and trust me, it is sweet. And don't worry, I'll get back to it in a moment, mmmmmmmmm, I just want to let your girlfriend finished cleaning my cock first. After all, it is obvious that she loves it, and we wouldn't want to deprive her, would we? No, oooooooooooh, we want Isabelle Lightwood to get every single drop of Clary Fray's ass cream. Then, you can return the favour. Ohhhhhhhhhh yessssssssss, I can't wait until you're sucking your girlfriend's butt juices off of Lizzie's cock. Or your own off mine. And I bet she feels the same way, don't you, Izzy?"
"Oh yes, Mistress Hope. Mmmmmmmmm, I'd love it." Izzy obediently answered when that cock was taken away from her, "Ooooooooooh Clary, I'd love to see you go ass to mouth. You don't have to, mmmmmmmmmm, but please try it. Just once. Ah fuck, if you love anal, chances are that you'll love ass to mouth. And you love it, don't you Clary?"
"Yeah, she does." Hope grinned, before shoving her cock back up Clary's sweet little booty.
Which naturally, caused Clary to cry out in a mixture of pain and pleasure. Again, she'd had worse, and it could've been worse, as Mistress Hope didn't shove it all inside her in one thrust, but it was a harder and quicker anal penetration and ass stuffing, and the fact that she could feel pleasure from it was extremely embarrassing. It showed how far she'd come in such a short time, and maybe suggest that she was just as much of a butt slut as Izzy was. Or maybe that this evil place was affecting her with magic. Clary took comfort in that for a while, but ultimately it didn't really matter, because the result was the same. Namely her being ass fucked, and loving every minute of it. Including what happened next.
Namely Lizzie pulling her cock out of Izzy's butt, moving around, and offering to Clary, "So, are you ready to taste your girlfriend's ass?"
Before any further encouragement Clary mentally said 'fuck it' and just got it over with. It was unlikely that she be spared this humiliation, so it had seemed like the right thing to do at that particular moment. Or maybe that was just an excuse? It was hard to tell, but she would be lying if she said she wasn't turned on by how much Dawn and Isabelle seemed to absolutely love it. And to her shame, she was no different, Clary moaning loudly and then eagerly sucking the ass flavoured cock. Again, she could tell herself it was because of the magic in this place, but in that moment it didn't really matter. No, all that mattered was getting every drop of that yummy butt cream, pleasing the more dominant women in the process. And more importantly to her, pleasing Izzy.
Clary had her eyes closed, but she could practically taste the wide grin on the other Shadowhunter's face as she gleefully encouraged her, "Yessssssssssss, oooooooooooooh fuckkkkkkkkkkkkk, that's it Clary! That's exactly it! By The Angel, I can't believe that Clarissa Fairchild is sucking my ass cream off of a cock. Ohhhhhhhhhhhh fuck, that's so hot. Take it all, Clary. Mmmmmmmmm yeahhhhhhhhhh, take it all the way down your pretty little throat. God, I love you Clary. I always have, ever since we first met, mmmmmmmmm, but I've never loved you more than right now Oh yes, mmmmmmmmm, I've never loved you more than when you're being taken in both ends like a total slut! Ooooooooooohhhhhhhhhh yeeeeeeeeeeessssssssssss, mmmmmmmmmm, take it Clary! Fucking take it all! Good girl. Ah fuck!"
Unsurprisingly the others gave her encouragement too, but Clary was only really paying attention to Izzy. This was very much the case for this whole experience. Well, whenever she was getting double stuffed, of course she had to focus most of her attention on sucking cock, especially when there was another one in her butt at the time. As such it was easier when Mistress Hope pulled her dick out of her ass, and gave it to Clary to clean. Of course, that was also her least favourite, as it meant that she wasn't receiving pleasure anymore. Or more accurately, she wasn't receiving physical pleasure. She was however receiving overwhelming mental pleasure, but she got that throughout. Which increasingly, was a big problem.
Over, and over, and over again Clary, Izzy and Dawn were made to go ass to mouth, even long after they had sampled all three flavours of ass being presented to them. Which was an ever-increasing frustration, given Clary's growing need to cum. And if she needed it, she couldn't imagine what poor Dawn and especially her poor Izzy was feeling right now. Actually, she didn't need to imagine it, as all she needed to do was turn her head from one side to the other. Which broke her heart, but what could she do about it? Then she realized what was expected of her, and it made her whimper pathetically. Because could she really do that? Lower herself that much? But then she realized, the answer was yes, as she would do anything for Isabelle Lightwood.
"Fuck me. Fuck me hard." Clary whimpered pathetically, becoming increasingly desperate as the seconds ticked by, "Oh yes, fuck my butt and make me cum! Ooooooooooooh yesssssssssss, butt fuck me! Butt fuck me hard! Oh please, mmmmmmmmmm, please, fuck me in the ass, and make me an anal slut. Make me your anal slut, if you have too. Oh yes, ohhhhhhhhhhhhh yeahhhhhhhhhhhh, that feels so good, soooooooooooo gooooooooooooddddddddddd, mmmmmmmmmmmm, AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH YEAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH, MAKE ME AN ASS WHORE! I WANNA BE A FUCKING ASS WHORE! OH MY GOD, I CAN'T BELIEVE IT FEELS THIS GOOD! OH GOD! AH FUCK, I LOVE IT IN THE FUCKING ASS! OH GOD, OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH GOOOOOOOOOOOOODDDDDDDDDDDDDD YEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEESSSSSSSSSSSSS, FUCK ME!"
"Me too, mmmmmmmmm, please Mistress Lizzie, fuck me!" Izzy moaned shamelessly right from the start, "Yesssssssssssss, oooooooooooh fuck, I need to be fucked! Fucked in the ass like the anal whore I am! Ohhhhhhhhhhhh yeahhhhhhhhhhhhh, butt fuck me, mmmmmmmmmm, and make me your anal bitch Mistress Lizzie, if you can! Yeahhhhhhhhhhh, you love that big booty, huh? Yessssssssssss, mmmmmmmmm, make those meaty cheeks jiggle for you, as you ass fuck me! Mmmmmmmm fuck yeah, pound my whore ass! OOOOOOOOOOOOOHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH YEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEESSSSSSSSSSSSSS, POUND FUCK MY FUCKING WHORE ASS! USE THAT FUCK HOLE! YEAHHHHHHHHHHHHHH, THAT'S WHAT IT'S FOR! MY FAT FUCKING ASS IS MADE FOR FUCKING! YES IT IS, OOOOOOOOOOOOOHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH YEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEESSSSSSSSSSSSSS, AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHH FUCKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK!"
"Me three." Dawn begged softly, trying not to take too much attention away from the Shadowhunters, as she knew Mistress Willow really wanted them to take centre stage, "Oooooooooooh yesssssssssss, bang my booty. Bang it like the anal slut I am! Mmmmmmmmmmmm yesssssssssss, use me as an example. Ohhhhhhhhhhh yeahhhhhhhhhh, use me as an example of what you want to turn the Shadowhunters into. Mmmmmmmmmm yeahhhhhhhhhhhhhh, they're gonna make such good butt sluts. Mmmmmmmmmm, just like me. I'm a good butt slut! I love it up the butt! Oh fuck! Oh yes, bang my butt, ooooooooooooh yessssssssssssss, bang it hard! Mmmmmmmmmm fuckkkkkkkkkkkkkk, fuck me, FUCK ME, FUCKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK MEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE, OOOOOOOOOOOOOOHHHHHHHHHHHHHH YEEEEEEEEEEEEEESSSSSSSSSSSSS, FUCK ME HARD AND WRECK MY FUCKING SHIT HOLE! AH FUCK! AAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH FUCKKKKKKKKKKKKKK! AH FUCK!"
It took a lot longer than Clary would've liked, but eventually the pace was increased. More importantly to her, even when she was been bombarding with overwhelming pleasure, poor Izzy had to wait even longer to get what she wanted. Dawn too. Apparently the other two tops were just content with watching the Alpha of their group butt fuck the anal virgin to climax. If she had realized that sooner, Clary wouldn't have tried to hold back, but it didn't really matter, because she was no match for Mistress Hope. No, with her eyes glowing yellow Mistress Hope gradually increased the pace, until she was using a supernatural amount of speed and strength, which would probably prevent poor Clary Fray from ever sitting properly again, or at least be able to do so without thinking about this goddess. And yet, it all felt amazing.
The only thing that could really compared to this was cumming in Isabelle Lightwood's mouth, and that was an extremely high bar. Hell, it might be even better than that. Or at least, it was, when Izzy started cumming too. Which took longer than Clary would have liked, but it happened. Oh yes, Clary Fray and Isabelle Lightwood started cumming from getting fucked in the ass side by side. And maybe best of all, the two Shadowhunters were able to hold hands the entire time, and occasionally even kiss, whenever they weren't too busy screaming in ecstasy. Which was more out of instinct than anything else, as they became mindless anal whores, sealing their fate within this prison as butt sex obsessed bottoms.
Lizzie loved fucking big fat jiggly asses, attached to dark haired beauties. It to become her favourite thing in the entire world, as it often allowed her to imagine her sister, and especially Hope, in the place of the ass whore she was enjoying. And at times like this, when Hope was distracted right by her side, it was easy to sneak a peek at her best friend's big booty, which would be jiggling like jelly even more than the bottoms. Or at least, that would normally be the case, but not with Isabelle Lightwood. No, Isabelle Lightwood's booty was so big, fat and jiggly, it had 90% of her attention right now, with the other 10% going to the sight of the now very much former anal virgin being turned into a total butt slut. Well, occasionally Lizzie thought about Hope and Josie, but mostly, she focused on the task at hand.
Mostly when she thought about them now, it was just to compare their performances. Which admittedly, was something she had always done, albeit under very different circumstances. She couldn't help it. She had always been insecure, but especially lately, when their asses were literally on the line. Unsurprisingly the tribrid seem to have almost unlimited stamina, which served her very well under these circumstances, but to her credit, Josie was able to keep up with her, at least for a little while. Maybe better than Lizzie was, honestly. And God, Lizzie soooooooooo needed to cum, it was becoming unbearable. So she decided to go out in style, smacking Isabelle's big booty, yanking back on her dark hair, and providing verbal encouragement.
"CUM! CUM FOR ME YOU LITTLE BITCH! NO! OOOOOOOOOOOOHHHHHHHHHHHH, CUM FOR ME YOU FAT ASSED BITCH!" Lizzie demanded almost angrily, "YESSSSSSSSSSS, FUCKING CUM! CUM LIKE THE BIG BOOTY WHORE YOU ARE! OOOOOOOOOOOOH YESSSSSSSSSSSSS, I DON'T KNOW WHAT YOU'LL BE, BUT RIGHT NOW? I OWN YOU! OH MY GOD, YESSSSSSSSSSSS, MMMMMMMMMM FUCKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK YEAHHHHHHHHHHHH, YOU'RE MY BIG BOOTY HO! MY FUCKING FUCK HOLE! MY ANAL LOVING LITTLE BITCH! OHHHHHHHHHHH YESSSSSSSSSSSSSSS, I LOVE BIG FAT ASSES! I WANT A BIG BOOTY BITCH SOOOOOOOOOOO BAD! MMMMMMMMM YEAHHHHHHHHH, I WANT AN ANAL BITCH WITH A BIG, FAT ASS! JUST! LIKE! YOU! LIKE AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH FUCKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK, LIKE, OOOOOOOOOOOOOHHHHHHHHHHHHH GOOOOOOOOOOOOODDDDDDDDDDDDDD!"
Maybe those words were too revealing, but thankfully Hope and Josie were clearly too preoccupied with pounding the hot little asses in front of them to really listen to what Lizzie was saying. Hell, Lizzie was barely aware of it herself, as the blonde got completely lost in the sodomy. Especially as those words combined with the other end of the dildo bashing against her clit, those meaty cheeks jiggling for her, and most of all, the sheer joy of ass fucking another woman, and a powerful supernatural creature at that, made sure that the blonde came nice and hard. She made sure to push herself through it, and several more climaxes for the both of them, but it was the beginning of the end.
Most embarrassing of all, she was the first to come to a complete stop, and pull out. Although to be fair, Josie was not far behind. Then Dawn and Isabelle reached back and slowly spread their cheeks, revealing two decent sized gapes, which the Saltzman twins could be proud of. It also added to the quite impressive show that their best friend was putting on, the ridiculously powerful Hope Mikaelson showing off that incredible power of hers as she maybe literally ruined poor Clary Fray's rectum. It certainly looked that way when finally Hope pulled out, and then after a nudge from her fellow Shadowhunter, Clary also reached back and spread her cheeks, presenting easily the widest gaping butt hole of them all. Maybe ever.
"So, what are you?" Hope questioned after savouring that sight for a few long seconds.
"Anal sluts!" Clary whimpered hoarsely, still in a state of mindless bliss as she added, "We're fuck holes, to be used by superior women. Like you, Mistress Hope. Used by you, and Mistress Josie, and Mistress Lizzie, mmmmmmmmmmm, anyone who wants us, our asses are yours! Oh God, please, please, please, someone fuck my ass! Someone, mmmmmmmmm, anyone? Ooooooooooooh yessssssssssss, ah fuck, I don't care how sore I get, I just want to be fucked! Fucked in the butt like an anal slut. I'm just a fuck hole, ohhhhhhhhhhhhh fuck, please treat me like one. Oh my God yes, just use me however, whenever, and wherever you want. I'm yours, and anyone who wants me."
"What she said." Izzy beamed.
"Good to hear." Willow beamed, as she and the other tops she had mentally called to join her entered the prison cell stroking their already equipped strap-ons, ready and eager to officially welcome the Shadowhunters to Prison Butt Fuck with a nice, long anal gang bang.
- 28
- 29
- 30
You need to be logged in to leave a review for this story.You need to be logged in to leave a review for this story.
Report Story

Gehanna