Adult-FanFiction.org : Buffy

Tales from Gehanna What If 1	By : MTLandLL Category: -Buffy the Vampire Slayer > FemmeSlash - Female/Female Views: 21103 -:- Recommendations : 2 -:- Currently Reading : 2
Disclaimer: I do not own Buffy the Vampire Slayer and have no association with anyone involved in either shows. I do not make any money from the writing of this story.

Chapter List
- 1
- 2
- 3
Willow had a dull recollection of being told hours lasted days inside her tiny box of a prison, but honestly it felt like she could've been there for weeks. It was just so hot and sticky, and impossible to think clearly, let alone keep track of time with the lust racing through her body. As the images had been mostly familiar she had given in to the urge to masturbate on the first night and had done little else since then. It was preferable to what would happen to her and her friends once they were released from the coolers, or was happening to the world with them trapped in here and Amy free to do what she wanted.

The funny thing is Willow kept waiting to get bored of fucking herself, but she never did, and she really wanted to do it again now. But a fresh prison uniform had been slid into her tiny room along with the promise that she will be let out in five minutes. She was pretty sure that was a lot longer than five minutes ago, and the guards were playing a mean trick on her, but as she didn't want to be caught with her hands literally down her pants she tried to stay strong, only for of course the door to open the second she mentally said 'fuck it' and try to give herself some sweet relief.

She tried to pull her hand out as quickly as she could, but it was no use, the guards saw her and smirked, their leader telling her, "Control yourself Rosenberg. It's time to meet your new cellie."

*

Faith through the ball against the wall and caught it in her left hand. She paused for a second and tossed it again, this time catching it in her right. Throw, bounce, catch-right; throw, bounce, catch-left - she repeated the moves endlessly as she sat alone in her cell.

The Slayer was so bored she was reduced to imitating Steve McQueen, if she had a motorbike she’d have gunned it at the wire for laughs. As she didn’t all she could do was bounce a baseball against her cell wall.

Throw, bounce, catch-left.

Throw, bounce, catch-right.

God, she was horny.

Turning her head the Slayer stared longingly across the hall. She always loved checking out the sluts across from her, but they had all been recently been removed to become the private sex slaves of some new big bad which had taken over. The sluts next door weren't helping either, noises of sexual pleasure coming from above, below and side to side of her, those sluts no doubt tonguing each other's pussies and ass holes. She had warned them about doing that shit when she didn't have a bitch on hand to service her needs, but still they did it, so eventually she gave up. That was the thing about sluts, particularly the ones that were willing to continue living next door to her without offering the Governor their firstborn child just to get away, they were tough, perhaps even tougher than the tops.

Fuck. Faith was so fucking horny she almost started fricking herself off, something she hadn't done in years, at least not to climax, and promised herself she would never do it again as long as she was stuck in this hell hole filled with sluts and bitches who should be satisfying her.

What she wouldn’t give for a new bitch to break in. Or a slut for a quick and easy fuck, but there was a lock-down in the wing whilst they brought in some new prisoners, so there she was stuck on her lonesome in her cell, playing catch against the wall.

"Lehane," there was a rap on the cell door. Faith stood up and smoothed down her clothes as the door opened and in stepped a guard, "Lehane, say hello to your new cellmate,"

Another guard pushed in a newcomer. It only took a second for Faith to recognise her, the redhead’s hair was shorter and she had filled out a bit, becoming a bit more bosomy and bit less gawky, but it was Buffy Summers's bestst pal Willow Rosenberg.

"Red," the Dark Slayer grinned as if she were a cat who had just been presented with a mouse with a broken leg on a silver platter.

"Faith…" Willow squeaked.

From the look on her face she remembered that she and The Dark Slayer hadn’t parted on best terms last time they met. Not that Faith bore a grudge, well not much of one, in fact Faith was sure that once she’d opened up Will’s butt hole and made her a slave that she hardly care that Will had helped send her to this place. Not right away though. No, Faith was going to savour this conquest, and let Willow obsess about what was going to happen to her, The Dark Slayer swearing she had a smirk plastered to her face for what felt like an hour as the guards mumbled something else, and then left leaving her soon to be bitch to back up against a wall and cower there.

*

Willow tried not to look at Faith, or give her any reason to hurt her, but it was disconcerting that this dangerous woman was staring at her like a jungle cat waiting to pounce. The only time Faith seem to break the stare was when her cigarette ran out and she had to light up a new one, the Dark Slayer smoking like a chimney for what felt like hours until she finally spoke, "You wanna know one of my favourite parts of breaking in a new bitch? The foreplay... I know right? Weird. Normally I'm not exactly... what's the word?"

"Sane?" Willow offered.

"I was going for patient, but hey, whatever." Faith said, getting up, "Gotta love the sass though. I just love it when a bitch gets all sassy right before a breakin’ in. Always gets me going... and if I remember it right you got plenty of sass don't you Red?"

As she came face to face with the redhead Faith took a long drag and then slowly, deliberately blew all the smoke into the redhead's face, causing her to cough and wheeze lightly.

"You remember that time I caught you snooping around City Hall, and then again in the private office the books of Ascension were kept? You know I always wished we got the chance to finish up rather than get so rudely interrupted, and now we're gonna." Faith said, pausing to smoke in Willow's face again before continuing, "Now where was I, oh yeah. One of my favourite parts of breaking in a new bitch is the foreplay. See, I could throw you down on the bed, tear off those pants and just fuck your ass right here, right now. Hell, if you were just about any other bitch I'd probably do it too, but see, you and me know each other."

Faith took another puff, quickly releasing it into Willow's face before continuing.

"Back in the day you always annoyed the fuck out of me. You were B's dorky little groupie who she was too soft to cut loose when you were doing nothing but hold her back. And you were always bitching about me to her behind my back. Fact, from what I hear you just kept bitching about me to everyone when you should've been kissing my ass for occasionally allowing B to let you tag along and get in the way. But all that's ok, because from now on you're going to be literally kissing my ass, among other things."

Another drag, and more coughing from Willow ensued.

"By the time I'm done beating on your ass it's going to be a fucking relief when my bitch making strap-on dick slams its way into your virgin ass."

More smoking, more coughing.

"Your ass is virgin, isn't it Will? Can't imagine wolf boy or that pathetic little dyke stepping up... and you smell, look, an act like a fucking virgin, so I'm guessing your nice and cherry back there. Course, I'd fuck your ass anyway, but virgin ass is like the fucking Holy Grail in this dump, and let me tell you, there's nothing better than fucking a nice tight little virgin ass."

More smoking, more coughing.

Then Faith noticed something, "God, this is fucking turning you on, isn't it?"

"No." Willow squeaked, not sounding at all convincing.

"Fuck, never saw this place's magic work so fast." Faith murmured, taking another drag and blowing more smoke into Willow's face before adding, "But then I guess it's different with lesbos."

"Hey, it's not my fault!" Willow protested, blushing bright red, "I, I got thrown in the coolers."

"Oh." Faith added in understanding, trying to remember when lock-down started in then smiling, "So, you've been here for about a week with no action?"

Willow nodded, and softly murmured, "Yes."

"Awww, poor baby." Faith laughed mockingly, taking another drag and blowing more smoke into Willow's face before adding, "I'll tell you what, to prove I'm not a monster, I'll skip the ass beating you have coming to you for now and just skip straight to the good stuff."

With that Faith put out her cigarette and then pulled her ugly orange prison top over her head, revealing a push-up bra which made it impossible for Willow not to glance at the other girl's tits. They looked even better once Faith removed the bra, giving Willow an unobstructed view of those perky C-cup titties with suck-able nipples which looked hard enough to cut glass. Willow was so mesmerised by those tits that she didn't notice Faith slipping off her shoes and socks with practised ease. She noticed the Slayer removing her orange prison bottoms, revealing Faith was going commando, and her wet pussy was very, very lick-able, Willow thinking she might have even unconsciously licked her lips.

Either way Faith smirked at her and said, "Well, don't just stand there you stupid dyke. Get on your knees and lick me."

Willow briefly hesitated, but as the smirk faded from Faith's face and was replaced with a stern look the Witch shuffled forward and slowly lowered herself to her knees, so she was face to face with the Slayer's cunt. That returned the wicked smirk to the brunette's face, Faith opening her mouth to talk more shit only for her words to dissolve into a long moan of pleasure as Willow lent forward and began lapping away at the admittedly tasty treat in front of her with quick little licks which continue to keep Faith quiet for a few blissful seconds.

Then Faith reached down, gripped her hair and groaned, "Fuck yeah, mmmmmmmmm, eat me bitch! Fucking eat my pussy! Oooooooooooh yeahhhhhhhhhh that's it, mmmmmmmmmm, I heard you became a cunt muncher, and it must be true because no way is this your first time. Oh fuck, mmmmmmmmmmm, or you were lying about just getting here, and I hope not, mmmmmmmm, cause I really want to be the one to pop your anal cherry. Ohhhhhhhhhhhh fuck yeah, I want to be the first one in that ass and put you in your fucking place for being mouthy back in Sunnydale, mmmmmmmm, not that I mind you being mouthy now, cause damn, do you eat good pussy!"

Doing her best to ignore what Faith was saying, and what might be happening to her real soon, Willow tried to relax and just enjoy what she had thought about doing for what was technically a week. Well, technically she had fantasised about fucking Faith for years, because as much as they might hate each other, The Dark Slayer was incredibly hot and fuck-able, and her cunt tasted even better than Willow had dreamed. But ever since she had been bought to this prison she had been unable to stop thinking about sex, having started touching herself shortly after she was thrown in the cooler and she hadn't really stopped until she was let out.

She had thought about eating Faith's pussy a lot during that time, because while it was one of her most forbidden fantasies it seemed preferable to some of the other thoughts threatening to invade her consciousness. Most noticeably thoughts of the people she came here with, her best friend Buffy and her best friend's little sister Dawn, to her shame Willow giving in a few times and fantasising about licking their pussies, and having them lick her, mostly separately, but once or twice at the same time. And that wasn't all, as she had imagined rimming them, them rimming her, and even having anal sex with them.

Willow had never seriously thought about having anal sex before, but over the past week she couldn't stop thinking about it. As imagining herself butt fucking other women made her feel guilty she mostly imagined herself on the receiving end. Well, she'd had a couple of vivid fantasies about ass fucking Faith, but it was hard to believe she would ever find herself in that position, so again Willow found herself cumming to the idea of The Dark Slayer sodomising her. Apparently that fantasy was about to come true, which scared Willow, but also excited her way more than it should.

All of a sudden Willow felt a yanking on her hair, followed by Faith yelling, "Stop day dreaming bitch! You've got work to do. Mmmmmmmmm fuck, lick me, fucking lick my cunt, oooooooooooh yeah, that's it. Now stick your tongue in me. Stick that nasty little tongue of yours deep into my pussy so I can cum on your face and then fuck you up the ass. Ohhhhhhhhhh yeahhhhhhhhh Will, I'm going to fuck you up the butt with my fucking cum drying on your face, you hear me? I'm gonna, oh fuck, fuck, fuckkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk yeahhhhhhhhhhhhh, aaaaaaaaaaaahhhhhhhhhhh oooooooooooooohhhhhhhhhhhhh shit!"

While thinking about the past week Willow had apparently slowed her licks right down to a level which didn't please Faith. Or one she didn't enjoy, or couldn't tolerate for more than a few minutes before demanding more. Willow suspected it was the former as it didn't feel like she had been licking pussy for that long, and as she didn't want to anger the supernaturally strong woman she briefly increased the force of her licks before ramming her tongue inside Faith as deep as it would go. Then she started tongue fucking her with everything she had, starting out hard and rough right from the get go which finally caused Faith to shut up. Or more accurately her words to becoming coherent.

Truth be told Willow wasn't just doing this out of fear of what Faith might do to her, or to distract herself from the fantasies she'd had over the past week. No, Willow was eating pussy, something she had grown to love during her relationship with Tara, and even though her beloved girlfriend was now gone Willow found she was enjoying this just as much. Sure, there was no emotional connection, but at least this confirmed she really was a pussy loving lesbian, because God did Faith taste good, Willow unable to get enough of the other woman's honey as it flowed into her mouth and pretty much directly down her throat.

Given that Faith began grinding her pussy into her face it was impossible for Willow to swallow all the brunette's juices but she tried her best and gulped down a fair amount in between rapid tongue thrusts which soon enough triggered a powerful orgasm. Tara had cum in her mouth a lot, but she had never squirted quite this powerfully, and in that moment Willow felt oddly proud of how much pleasure she was able to give Faith. Mostly though she just tried to swallow as much as Faith's cum as possible, Willow completely giving up on the tongue fucking in favour of literally sucking the cum out of Faith.

For her part Faith nearly broke Willow's nose with the forceful face fucking she gave her, The Slayer not just humping her face but using both hands to grip her red hair forcefully and pull her in with each hard thrust. For a few tense seconds The Witch was scared for her life. Then she was shoved face down on the bed so that her lower half was hanging off the edge, Faith surprisingly giving her a few minutes to recover. However that was only so Faith could retrieve a big strap-on, Willow looking behind her just in time to see the other girl stepping into it and pulling it up her thighs.

As she secured the harness around her waist Faith grinned down at her pray and announced, "I don't always lube for bitches, but I'm in a good mood and as you turned out to be a pretty damn fine rug muncher I'll make it easy on us both."

With that Faith pull out a bottle of lubricant, squirted some over her newly acquired cock and then started rubbing it in like it was real, a wicked grin glued to her face the entire time. That made Willow blush and face forwards, although she was very grateful for the lube as she lay there trembling in anticipation and fear. Then Faith kneeled down behind her and spent a minute or so fondling her butt through the orange prison bottoms before slowly pulling them down to reveal her vulnerable little ass.

"Wow, cute butt." Faith grinned, "I'm really going to love fucking it."

Willow knew if she was going to save her own ass hole now was her last opportunity to do anything about it. But really, what could she do at this point? If she had her powers it would be one thing, or even just a fraction of them, but it felt like this place had drained her of every drop of magic in her body, leaving her completely helpless. So more or less what she had been when she first met Faith, and The Dark Slayer was obviously determined to take advantage of that and get revenge on her. Even if Willow asked her to be gentle that would probably only push her to be rough, so really all Willow could do was try and relax and hope that Faith decided to take it easy on her.

At first it looked like she might be actually be in luck as Faith took maybe a minute or two just staring at her ass, and then playing with her vulnerable little cheeks. However that was apparently just to build up the anticipation, because shortly after that Faith pulled one of Willow's ass cheeks to the side with one hand while using the other to pressed the head of her dildo against the redhead's virgin butt hole and then slammed forwards, popping Willow's anal cherry with one hard thrust which caused the usually powerful Witch to cry out pathetically in pain.

Which of course made Faith laugh cruelly and yelled, "Yeah, take it Red! Fucking take it!"

Faith said more, a lot more, mostly talking trash in between growling 'take it' over and over again but Willow was far too preoccupied with the dildo rocketing up her back chute, her face contorting in discomfort as she let out more yelps of pain. At least Faith didn't shove it up her ass all at once, something she could have easily done with her Slayer strength, but it was small mercy. Then again maybe Gehanna had robbed Faith of her strength in the same way it had robbed Willow of her magic and all the brunette could do was deliver a series of semi hard thrusts, which slowly stuffed her strap-on into the redhead's back passage.

Either way Willow found herself clawing at the bed sheets like someone trying to pull their way out of quicksand, but like in metaphor it was no use and it even felt like the more she struggled the deeper she sunk, or in this case the deeper Faith sunk her strap-on into Willow's now formally virgin ass. Faith certainly she enjoyed the way Willow struggled, although it had nothing on The Dark Slayer's reaction to her hips crashing against the Witch's butt cheeks, announcing that the entire length of her 'cock' was now inside Willow's rectum, Willow's anal virginity thoroughly taken and claimed.

"Fuck yeah! Ya ass is mine Red!" Faith laughed, "All fucking mine! Your nerdy loser ass is mine and your my fucking bitch!"

Willow whimpered and buried her face in the bed sheets. Again what could she do other than that? Apparently the answer to that was lift up her head and cry out as Faith pulled her hips back, about half of the dildo easily sliding out of her rectum, and then the evil brunette slammed forward, ramming every inch of the strap-on back up Willow's butt in a second. Faith then repeated the process, officially beginning Willow's first ever ass fucking, taunting her every step of the way.

"Your ass is mine Red! Mmmmmmm, I got ya cherry and now your tight little ass hole is my personal fuck hole!" Faith gleefully told her latest victim, "Ohhhhhhhhh yeahhhhhhhhhh, sooooooooo tight! Mmmmmmmmm, this tight little butt hole is all mine now Red! I own it! I own you, cause this is Prison Butt Fuck. Officially, they call it Gehanna, but to me it will always be Prison Butt Fuck, cause in this shit hole ya take another girl's ass and she's yours. And that's what I've done here, taken your ass and made it mine. Mmmmmmmm yeahhhhhhhhhh, ya gonna be nothing but my prison bitch from now on Red, ooooooooooh yeahhhhhhhhh, eating my pussy and taking it up the ass, oooooooooohhhhhhhhh shit, bein' my personal whore, oh fuck, bein' my fuckin' fuck toy and takin' it in ya shit hole like a bitch, aaaaaaaaahhhhhhhhhh fuck yeah, take it like a bitch Will! Cause that's all you are now. My bitch."

The most humiliating thing about those words was that they were turning Willow on, and it wasn't a mildly pleasant distraction from the agony of having her rectum unnaturally stretched. No, this was like pouring gasoline on the raging fire of her quickly growing lust, Willow soon having to bury her face in the bed sheets to hide her moans of pleasure instead of cries of pain. Fortunately Faith didn't notice as she was too busy taunting Willow while fucking her ass, and occasionally smacking it, which was just another thing which shouldn't be pleasant but somehow it was.

Willow told herself it had to be magic. And it made sense as ever since she got here, she couldn't stop thinking about butt sex, even to the point where she had imagined butt fucking her best friend Buffy and her best friend's baby sister Dawn. As it made her feel less guilty she had more frequently imagine them fucking her ass, and more than once she fantasised about getting sodomised by Faith, the reality far better than the fantasy, if only because of the magic of this place. Although Willow could believe the skilful feeling thrusts were a result of plenty of practice rather than any outside interference, just as she could believe Faith was at least partly responsible for her current enjoyment.

She didn't want to ever admit it out loud but it was so hot to be at Faith's mercy. At least all The Dark Slayer wanted was to sexually dominate her, and Willow had never felt more dominated than at this moment. Could never imagine a more submissive feeling than being fucked up the ass, and despite herself she was loving that feeling of submission. And that feeling, combined with places inside her being stimulated which should have never been touched, and getting to see Faith naked and eat her pussy, and most importantly of all the magic of this evil place, made Willow cum.

It wasn't just a normal orgasm either, like the ones she'd had masturbating alone in the cooler, or even making love to her sweet Tara. This was an explosion which shattered every part of her being and made her tingle all over, Willow letting out a guttural scream of pleasure for as long as the climax lasted. Then she was hit with another, and another, and another, and then her world went black as for the first time in her life she was fucked into unconsciousness, the last thing that she was aware of being Faith savagely violating her ass hole while swearing like a sailor at her.

*

Faith yawned and stretched shortly after the horrible screech of the tannoy announced it was breakfast time and the cell doors were unlocked. Then recollection flooded back to her and she sat up and took a look to her right to see if last night had been a dream. Technically it wasn't rock solid proof, as Faith had woken up plenty of times to find a freshly gaped butt hole staring at her and it didn't mean that she had taken Willow Rosenberg's butt cherry last night, but she just had this feeling in her bones and as she got up and practically skipped over to her latest conquest. She was delighted to discover first red hair and then Willow's face, Faith grinned proudly down at her new piece of ass.

Seemed that her new bitch was still unconscious, which was actually a regular occurrence despite how loud the tannoy was. In these situations Faith knew the perfect way to wake up her new anal whore, and make absolutely sure Willow knew what's what. Perhaps most importantly of all it would widen the already impressive gape, so that when Faith made Willow expose her butt hole at breakfast that could be no doubt she had thoroughly broken in the newcomer. After all, Faith had a reputation to uphold, and she couldn't do that with a baby gape. Or perhaps teenaged gape would be more accurate. No, Faith wanted a nice big adult gape, the once high and mighty Willow Rosenberg a whimpering mess with an ass hole as wide as the Grand Canyon.

With that in mind Faith kneeled down behind Willow and giggled, "Wakey wakey bitch."

Faith then clenched her fist and rammed the whole thing up Willow's ass in one hard thrust, causing the Witch to jolt upwards and scream loudly. Which just made The Dark Slayer laugh cruelly and gripped tightly to her bitch's waist so no matter how much she struggled Willow couldn't go anywhere. For the first few seconds it was even kind of difficult for Faith, but the fight slowly drained out of Willow as she once again began to be anally pounded, this time with a clenched fist, Faith going slow at first, so she could savour the moment, and how tight the newcomer's ass was.

"Still so tight Will." Faith grinned, "We're gonna have to work on that."

Willow just whimpered in response and let Faith use her ass for her pleasure. Just how Faith liked her women. But like with every other bitch she'd ever had whimpers and cries of pain and discomfort soon turned to whimpers and cries of pleasure as Willow's shit pipe slowly relaxed and once again became used to being the fuck passage it now was. Which was Faith's cue to increase the pace, and while sometimes she liked to tease her bitches, and would no doubt be doing with Willow soon enough, right now she was just in the mood for some of hard-core fisting action.

So Faith slowly but surely began increasing the pace, pulling her fist almost all the way out each time so she could watch it stretch Willow's ass hole obscenely wide before ramming forwards and pushing her hand as deep into the other girl's ass as it would go. For a moment Faith thought she'd eventually get up to her elbow, but looking down she realised she actually hadn't got that much further at all. Oh well, there was always later. She was still having a lot of fun, especially now Willow was screaming at what had to be the up of her lungs and covering the bed sheets, Faith honestly unsure whether the witch was in hell or heaven right now. It was probably a bit of both, at least in the beginning of the hard fisting.

Then cum started squirting out of Willow's cunt in what had to be record time. Or not, Faith tearing her eyes away from Willow for the first time in a long time to look at her clock and discover she had just got lost in anally fisting her new bitch. Whatever, Faith shrugged. She had only begun Willow's training, and by the time Faith was done with her and kicked her out like all the other pieces of trash she used for her pleasure Willow would be the biggest butt slut in Gehanna.

While there was probably more work to be done on training Willow's ass hole to be a good fuck hole the woman herself already seemed thoroughly broken in, even screaming 'yes', 'more' and 'fuck me harder' over and over for a while. Even when she became incoherent, and when eventually Faith stopped, Willow whimpered in pure pleasure, first loudly and then softly while her body trembled. And to be fair on Faith, she didn't spend that long fisting Willow's ass. At least not compared to some of the other women she had broken in. Mostly because she was hungry and wanted to eat, but it was at least partly out of pity.

Besides, she had proven her point about who was in charge again and further stretched Willow's butt, Faith taking a few moments to stare at the damage to that butt hole after she pulled her fist out of it and then announced, "Get dressed bitch. It's time to get some grub, and show your bitch ass off."
- 1
- 2
- 3
You need to be logged in to leave a review for this story.You need to be logged in to leave a review for this story.
Report Story

Tales from Gehanna What If 1